ON THE USEFULNESS OF STOVE PIPES

T was evident that, without suspecting it, and moved only by their chivalrous and adventurous character, our three friends had just rendered a service to someone whom the cardinal honored with his particular protection.
Now, who was this someone? That was the question the three musketeers first asked themselves; then, seeing that none of the answers their intelligence could supply was satisfactory, Porthos called the host and asked for dice. Porthos and Aramis sat down at a table and began to play; Athos walked about thinking.
While thinking and walking, Athos passed and repassed before the pipe of the stove, broken in half, the other end of which opened into the room above, and each time he passed and repassed he heard a murmur of words that ended by fixing his attention. Athos approached and distinguished a few words which seemed to him doubtless to deserve such great interest that he signaled to his two companions to be silent, remaining himself bent over, his ear stretched to the height of the lower opening.
"Listen, milady," said the cardinal, "the affair is important. Sit down there and let us talk."
"Milady!" murmured Athos.
"I am listening to Your Eminence with the greatest attention," replied a woman's voice that made the musketeer start.
"A small vessel with an English crew, whose captain is mine, awaits you at the mouth of the Charente, at the fort of the Pointe; it will set sail tomorrow morning.
“Then I must go there tonight.”
“This very moment—that is to say, when you have received my instructions. Two men whom you will find at the door will serve as your escort. You will let me go out first;then, half an hour after me, you will go out in your turn.”
“Yes, my lord. Now let us return to the mission with which you are good enough to charge me; and as I wish to continue to deserve Your Eminence’s confidence, deign to set it before me in clear and precise terms, so that I commit no error.”
There was a moment of deep silence between the two interlocutors; it was evident that the cardinal was measuring in advance the terms in which he was about to speak, and that milady was gathering all her intellectual faculties to understand the things he was going to say and to engrave them in her memory once they were said.
Athos took advantage of this moment to tell his two companions to close the door on the inside and to signal to them to come and listen with him.
The two musketeers, who loved their comforts, brought a chair for each of them and a chair for Athos. All three sat down, heads close together and ears alert.
“You are going to leave for London,” resumed the cardinal. “Once arrived in London, you will go find Buckingham.”
“I will point out to His Eminence,” said milady, “that since the affair of the diamond studs, for which the duke has always suspected me, His Grace distrusts me.”
“So this time,” said the cardinal, “it is no longer a question of winning his confidence, but of presenting yourself frankly and loyally as a negotiator.”
“Frankly and loyally?” repeated milady with an indescribable expression of duplicity.
“Yes, frankly and loyally,” resumed the cardinal in the same tone; “this whole affair must be conducted openly.”
“I will follow His Eminence’s instructions to the letter, and I await his giving them to me.”
“You will go find Buckingham on my behalf and tell him that I know all the preparations he is making, but that I scarcely trouble myself about them, since at the first movement he risks, I lose the queen.”
“Will he believe that Your Eminence is in a position to carry out the threat you make against him?”
“Yes, for I have proofs.”
“I must be able to present these proofs for his consideration.”
“No doubt, and you will tell him that I am publishing the report of Bois-Robert and the Marquis de Beautru on the interview the duke had at Madame la Connétable’s with the queen on the evening when Madame la Connétable gave a masked ball; you will tell him, so that he doubts nothing, that he came there in the costume of the Great Mogul that the Chevalier de Guise was to wear, and that he bought it from the latter for the sum of three thousand pistoles.”
“Very well, my lord.”
“All the details of his entry into the Louvre and of his exit during the night when he introduced himself into the palace in the costume of an Italian fortune-teller are known to me; you will tell him, so that he may not doubt the authenticity of my information, that under his cloak he had a large white robe, sown with black tears, death’s heads, and crossbones; for in case of surprise, he was to pass himself off as the ghost of the white lady, who, as everyone knows, returns to the Louvre every time some great event is about to take place.”
“Is that all, my lord?”
“Tell him that I also know all the details of the adventure of Amiens; that I will have a cleverly turned little novel made of it, with a plan of the garden and the portraits of the principal actors in that nocturnal scene.”
“I will tell him that.”
“Tell him also that I hold Montaigu, that Montaigu is in the Bastille, that no letter was taken on him, it is true, but that torture can make him say all he knows and even . . . what he does not know.”
“Admirable.”
“Finally, add that His Grace, in the haste he made to leave the Ile de Ré, forgot in his lodging a certain letter from Madame de Chevreuse which singularly compromises the queen, in that it proves not only that Her Majesty can love the king’s enemies, but also that she conspires with those of France. You have remembered well all that I have said to you, have you not?”
“Your Eminence shall judge: the ball at Madame la Connétable’s, the night at the Louvre, the evening at Amiens, the arrest of Montaigu, the letter from Madame de Chevreuse—”
“That is it,” said the cardinal, “that is it; you have a very happy memory, milady.”
“But,” resumed the one to whom the cardinal had just addressed this compliment, “if, in spite of all these reasons, the duke does not yield and continues to threaten France?”
“The duke is in love like a madman, or rather like a fool,” resumed Richelieu with a profound bitterness. “Like the ancient paladins, he has undertaken this war only to obtain a glance from his fair one. If he knows that this war may cost the honor and perhaps the liberty of the lady of his thoughts, as he says, I answer you that he will look twice.”
“And yet,” said milady with a persistence that proved she wanted to see clearly to the very end in the mission with which she was about to be charged, “and yet if he persists?”
“If he persists?” said the cardinal. “. . . That is not probable.”
“It is possible,” said milady.
“If he persists? . . .” His Eminence paused and resumed: “If he persists, well then! I will hope in one of those events which change the face of states.”
“If His Eminence would cite for me in history some of those events,” said milady, “perhaps I would share his confidence in the future?”
“Well then! take, for example,” said Richelieu, “when in 1610, for a cause almost similar to the one that moves the duke, King Henri IV, of glorious memory, was about to invade both Flanders and Italy in order to strike Austria from both sides—well then! did not an event occur that saved Austria? Why should the King of France not have the same chance as the Emperor?”
“Your Eminence means the knife thrust in the Rue de la Péronnerie.”
“Exactly,” said the cardinal.
“Does Your Eminence not fear that the torture of Ravaillac will terrify those who might for a moment have the idea of imitating him?”
“There will be at all times and in all countries, especially if those countries are divided in religion, fanatics who will ask for nothing better than to make themselves martyrs. And, look, just now it comes back to me that the Puritans are furious against the Duke of Buckingham, and that their preachers designate him as the Antichrist.”
“Well?” said milady. “Well!” continued the cardinal with an indifferent air, “it would be a question for the moment, for example, only of finding a woman, beautiful, young, skillful, who had to avenge herself on Buckingham. Such a woman may be met with. The duke is a man of good fortunes, and if he has sown many loves by his promises of eternal constancy, he must also have sown many hatreds by his eternal infidelities.” “No doubt,” said milady coldly, “such a woman may be met with.”
— Well then! such a woman who would put the knife of Jacques Clément or the Ravaillac into the hands of a fanatic would save France.
— Yes, but she would be the accomplice of an assassination.
— Have the accomplices of Ravaillac or of Jacques Clément ever been known?
— No, for perhaps they were placed too high for anyone to dare go looking for them where they were. The Palais de Justice would not be burned down for everyone, monseigneur.
— You believe, then, that the burning of the Palais de Justice has a cause other than chance? asked Richelieu in the tone with which he would have asked a question of no importance.
“I, monseigneur,” replied milady, “I believe nothing; I cite a fact, that is all. Only, I say that if my name were Madame de Montpensier or Queen Marie de Médicis, I would take fewer precautions than I take, being simply Lady Clarick de Winter.”
“That is just,” said Richelieu; “what would you want, then?”
“I would want an order ratifying in advance all that I shall believe it my duty to do for the greatest good of France.”
“But first it would be necessary to find the woman I told you of, who would have to avenge herself on the duke.”
“She is found,” said milady.
“Then it would be necessary to find that wretched fanatic who will serve as the instrument of God’s justice.”
“He will be found.”
“Well!” said the cardinal, “then it will be time to claim the order you asked for just now.”
“Your Eminence is right,” resumed milady, “and it is I who was wrong to see in the mission with which she honors me anything other than what it really is, that is to say, to announce to His Grace, on the part of His Eminence, that you know the various disguises by means of which he contrived to approach the queen during the fête given by Madame la Comtesse; that you have the proofs of the extreme favor granted at the Louvre by the queen to a certain Italian astrologer, who is none other than the Duke of Buckingham; that you have ordered a most witty little romance on the adventure of Amiens, with a plan of the garden where that adventure took place, and portraits of the actors who figured in it; that Montaigu is at the Bastille, and that torture can make him say the things he remembers and even the things he would have forgotten; finally, that you possess a certain letter from Madame de Chevreuse, found in His Grace’s lodgings, which singularly compromises not only the one who wrote it, but also the one in whose name it was written. Then, if he persists in spite of all that, as it is to what I have just said that my mission is limited, I shall have no more to do than to pray God to work a miracle to save France. That is it, is it not, monseigneur, and I have nothing else to do?”
“That is it,” replied the cardinal dryly.
“And now,” said milady, without appearing to notice the change in the cardinal-duke’s tone toward her, “now that I have received Your Eminence’s instructions concerning his enemies, will monseigneur permit me to say two words about mine?”
“So you have enemies?” said Richelieu.
“Yes, monseigneur, enemies against whom you owe me your support, for I have made them in serving Your Eminence.”
“And which ones?” replied the duke.
“First there is a little intriguer by the name of Bonacieux.”
“She is in the prison of Mantes.”
“That is to say, she was there,” resumed milady, “but the queen surprised an order from the king, with the help of which she had her transported to a convent.”
“To a convent?” said the duke.
“Yes, to a convent.”
“And which one?”
“I do not know; the secret was well kept.”
“I shall know it, I!”
“And will Your Eminence tell me in which convent that woman is?”
“I see no objection,” replied the cardinal.
“Good. Now, I have another enemy far more to be feared by me than that little Madame Bonacieux.”
“And which one?”
“Her lover.”
“What is his name?”
“Oh! Your Eminence knows him well,” cried milady, carried away by anger; “he is the evil genius of us both; it is he who in an encounter with Your Eminence’s guards decided the victory in favor of the king’s musketeers; it is he who gave three sword thrusts to de Wardes, your ensign; and who caused the affair of the diamond studs to fail; it is he, finally, who, knowing that it was I who had carried off Madame Bonacieux, has sworn my death.”
“Ah, ah!” said the cardinal, “I know of whom you speak.”
“I mean that wretch d’Artagnan.”
“He is a bold fellow,” said the cardinal.
“And it is precisely because he is a bold fellow that he is all the more to be feared.”
“It would be necessary,” said the duke, “to have a proof of his intelligences with Buckingham.”
“A proof?” cried milady, “I will have ten!”
“Well! then, it is the simplest thing in the world; have me that proof and I send him to the Bastille.”
“Good, monseigneur, but afterward?”
“When one is at the Bastille, there is no afterward,” said the cardinal in a dull voice. “Ah! by God!” he continued, “if it were as easy for me to rid myself of my enemy as it is easy for me to rid you of yours, and if it were against such people that you asked me for impunity…”
“Monseigneur,” resumed milady, “troc for troc, existence for existence, man for man: give me that one, I give you the other.”
“I do not know what you mean,” replied the cardinal, “and do not even wish to know; but I desire to be agreeable to you and see no objection to giving you what you ask me with regard to so insignificant a creature, all the more since, as you tell me, that little d’Artagnan is a libertine, a duellist, a traitor.”
“An infamous man! monseigneur, an infamous man!”
“Give me then some paper, a pen and ink,” said the cardinal.
“Here they are, monseigneur.”
“Good.”
There was a moment of silence which proved that the cardinal was occupied in seeking the terms in which the note was to be written, or even in writing it. Athos, who had not lost a word of the conversation, took his two companions each by a hand and led them to the other end of the room.
“Well!” said Porthos, “what do you want? and why do you not let us listen to the end of the conversation?”
“Hush!” said Athos, speaking in a low voice, “we have heard all that it is necessary for us to hear; besides, I am not preventing you from listening to the rest, but I must go out.”
“You must go out?” said Porthos; “but if the cardinal asks for you, what shall we answer?”
“You will not wait for him to ask for me; you will tell him first that I have gone to reconnoiter, because certain words from our host have given me to think that the road was not safe; I will moreover say a word or two about it to the cardinal’s equerry; the rest concerns me, do not worry about it.”
“Be prudent, Athos,” said Aramis.
“Be easy,” replied Athos, “you know I have cool blood.”
Porthos and Aramis went to take their places again near the stovepipe.
As for Athos, he went out without any mystery, went to take his horse, tied with those of his two friends at the turnstile of the shutters, convinced the squire in four words of the necessity of a vanguard for the return, ostentatiously inspected the priming of his pistols, took his sword between his teeth, and followed like a lost child the road that led to the camp.