Skip to main content
Les Trois MousquetairesAlexandre Dumas

THE RETURN.

D'Artagnan had remained stunned by Athos's terrible confidence. Many things still seemed obscure to him in this half-revelation. In the first place, it had been made by a man thoroughly drunk to a man who was half drunk; and yet, despite the vagueness that the fumes of two or three bottles of Burgundy raise to the brain, d'Artagnan, on waking the next morning, had every word of Athos as present to his mind as if, as they had fallen from the one's mouth, they had been imprinted in the other's mind.

All this doubt only gave him a keener desire to arrive at certainty, and he went to his friend's with the firm intention of resuming their conversation of the previous day; but he found Athos with his senses altogether settled, that is to say, the most subtle and the most impenetrable of men.

Besides, the musketeer, after exchanging with him a smile and a handshake, was the first to anticipate his thought:

— I was very drunk yesterday, my dear d'Artagnan, he exclaimed; I felt it this morning by my tongue, which was still very thick, and by my pulse, which was still very agitated. I wager I uttered a thousand extravagances.

And saying these words, he looked at his friend with a fixedness that embarrassed him.

— But no, replied d'Artagnan, and if I remember rightly, you said nothing but what was quite ordinary.

— Ah! you astonish me; I thought I had told you one of the most lamentable stories.

And he looked at the young man as if he would read to the depths of his soul.

— Upon my word, said d'Artagnan, it seems I was even drunker than you, since I remember nothing.

Athos did not accept this statement, and he went on:

— You cannot have failed to notice, my dear friend, that everyone has his own kind of drunkenness, sad or gay. I have the sad kind, and once I am tipsy, my mania is to tell all the gloomy stories that my foolish nurse instilled into my head. That is my failing, a capital failing, I admit; but apart from that, I am a good drinker.

Athos said this in so natural a manner that d'Artagnan was shaken in his conviction.

— Oh! so that is it indeed, resumed the young man, trying to grasp the truth again; so that is why I remember, as one remembers a dream, that we spoke of hanged people.

— Ah! you see, said Athos, paling, but trying to laugh; I was sure of it; hanged people are my nightmare.

— Yes, yes, resumed d'Artagnan, and now memory returns to me... yes, it was about... wait, then, it was about a woman.

— See, replied Athos, becoming almost livid, it is my great story of the fair-haired woman, and when I tell that one, it is that I am dead drunk.

— Yes, that is it, said d'Artagnan, the story of the fair-haired woman, tall and beautiful with blue eyes.

— Yes, and hanged.

— By her husband, who was a lord of your acquaintance, continued d'Artagnan, looking fixedly at Athos.

— Well, see, nevertheless, how one would compromise a man when one no longer knows what one is saying, resumed Athos, shrugging his shoulders as if he had taken himself in pity. Decidedly, I will no longer get drunk, d'Artagnan; it is too bad a habit.

D'Artagnan kept silent; and then, suddenly changing the conversation:

— By the way, said Athos, I thank you for the horse you brought me.

— Is it to your taste?

— Yes, but it was not a horse for hard riding.

— You are mistaken; I covered ten leagues with him in less than an hour and a half, and he showed no more sign of it than if he had gone around the Place Saint-Sulpice.

— Well now, you are going to make me regret it.

— Regret it?

— Yes, I have disposed of him.

— How so?

— This is the fact: this morning I awoke at six o'clock, you were sleeping like a deaf man, and I did not know what to do; I was still all dazed from our debauch of yesterday; I went down into the great hall and noticed one of our Englishmen bargaining for a horse from a horse dealer, his own having died yesterday of a fit of apoplexy. I approached him, and as I saw that he was offering a hundred pistoles for a chestnut: By Jove, I said to him, my gentleman, I too have a horse to sell.

“And a very handsome one, too,” he said; “I saw it yesterday, your friend’s servant had it in his hand.”

“Do you think it is worth a hundred pistoles?”

“Yes. And you want to give it to me for that price—?”

“No; but I will play you for it.”

“At what?”

“At dice.”

No sooner said than done, and I lost the horse. Ah! but, for instance, continued Athos, I won back the caparison.

D’Artagnan made a rather sullen face.

“Does that vex you?” said Athos.

“Why, yes, I confess it does,” replied D’Artagnan; “that horse was to have served to recognize us on a day of battle; it was a pledge, a remembrance. Athos, you were wrong.”

“Eh! my dear friend, put yourself in my place,” resumed the Musketeer; “I was bored to death, myself; and then, on my honor, I don’t like English horses. Come, if it is only a question of being recognized by someone, well then! the saddle will do; it is remarkable enough. As for the horse, we will find some excuse to account for its disappearance. Hang it! a horse is mortal; let us suppose mine had the glanders or the farcy.

D’Artagnan did not unbend.

“It vexes me,” continued Athos, “that you seem to care so much about these animals, for I am not at the end of my story.”

“What have you done besides?”

— After losing my horse, nine against ten (see the blow!), the idea came to me to play yours.

— Yes; but you stopped at the idea, I hope?

— Not at all, I put it into execution that very instant.

— Ah! upon my word! cried d'Artagnan, uneasy.

— I played and I lost.

— My horse?

— Your horse, seven against eight; short by one point... you know the proverb?...

— Athos, you are not in your right senses, I swear to you.

— My dear fellow, it was yesterday, when I was telling you my foolish stories, that you should have said that to me, and not this morning. So I lost it, with all possible trappings and harness.

— But that is frightful!

— Wait, then, you are not there yet; I should be an excellent gamester if I did not get obstinate; but I get obstinate; it's like when I drink. So I got obstinate.

— But what could you play? you had nothing left.

— Yes, indeed, yes, indeed, my friend; there was still left to you that diamond which shines on your finger, and which I had noticed yesterday.

— That diamond, cried d'Artagnan, hastily carrying his hand to his ring.

— And as I am a connoisseur, having had some for my own account, I had valued it at a thousand pistoles.

— I hope, said d'Artagnan seriously, half dead with fright, that you made no mention at all of my diamond?

— On the contrary, dear friend; you understand, that diamond became our only resource; with it I could win back our harness and our horses, and even money for the journey.

— Athos, you make me shudder! cried d'Artagnan.

— So I spoke of your diamond to my partner, who had also noticed it. Hang it! my dear fellow, you wear a star of heaven on your finger, and you don't want people to notice it? Impossible.

— Finish, my dear fellow, finish..., said d'Artagnan, for, on my honor, with your coolness, you are killing me.

— So we divided that diamond into ten parts of a hundred pistoles each.

— Ah! you mean to laugh and try me, said d'Artagnan, whom anger was beginning to seize by the hair as Minerva seizes Achilles in the Iliad.

— No, I am not jesting, by God! I should have liked to see you there, you! It was a fortnight since I had looked on a human face, and I was there stupefying myself by tippling with bottles.

— That is no reason for playing my diamond! answered d'Artagnan, clenching his hand with a nervous contraction.

— Just hear the end. Ten parts of a hundred pistoles each, in ten casts, without revenge. In thirteen casts, I lost everything. In thirteen casts! The number thirteen has always been fatal to me; it was the thirteenth of July that...

— Zounds! cried d'Artagnan, rising from the table, the story of the day making him forget that of the day before.

— Patience! said Athos. I had a plan; the Englishman was an odd fellow; I had seen him in the morning talking with Grimaud, and Grimaud had warned me that he had made him proposals to enter his service. I played him Grimaud, the silent Grimaud, divided into ten portions.

— Ah! this time! said d'Artagnan, bursting into laughter.

— Grimaud himself, do you hear that; and with the ten parts of Grimaud, who is not worth a whole ducaton, I won back the diamond. Tell me now that persistence is not a virtue.

— Faith, it's very droll, cried d'Artagnan, consoled and holding his sides with laughter.

— You understand that, feeling myself in luck, I immediately set to playing again on the diamond.

— Ah, hang it! said d'Artagnan, gloomy again.

— I won back your harness, then your horse; then my harness, then my horse; then lost again. In short, I recovered your harness, then mine. That is where we stand. It is a superb stroke; so I stopped there.

D'Artagnan breathed as if the inn had been lifted off his chest.

— At last the diamond is left me, he said timidly.

— Intact, dear friend. Plus the harness of your Bucephalus and of mine.

— But what shall we do with our harness without horses?

— I have an idea about them.

— Athos, you make me shudder.

— Listen. You have not played for a long time, you, d'Artagnan?

— And I have no wish to play.

— Let us swear to nothing. You have not played for a long time, I was saying, so you must have a good hand.

— Well! and after?

— Well! the Englishman and his companion are still here. I noticed that they greatly regret the harness; you, you seem attached to your horse; in your place, I would play your harness against your horse.

— But he will not want a single harness.

— Play both, by God; I am not an egoist like you, I.

— You would do that? said d'Artagnan undecided, so much was Athos's confidence beginning to win him over in spite of himself.

— Word of honor, in a single cast.

— But the fact is, having lost the horses, I was extremely anxious to keep at least the harness.

— Play your diamond, then.

— Oh! that is another thing; never! never!

— Hang it! said Athos, I would gladly propose to you to play Planchet, but as that has already been done, the Englishman might not want to again.

— Decidedly, my dear Athos, said d'Artagnan, I prefer to risk nothing.

— It's a pity, said Athos coldly, the Englishman is lined with pistoles. Eh! my God! try one cast; a cast is soon played.

— And if I lose?

— You will win.

— But if I lose.

— Well! you will give the harness.

— Done for one cast, said d'Artagnan.

Athos went in search of the Englishman and found him in the stable, where he was examining the harnesses with an eye of covetousness. The opportunity was a good one. He set his conditions: the two harnesses for a horse or a hundred pistoles, his choice. The Englishman calculated quickly: the two harnesses were well worth three hundred pistoles between them; he struck the bargain.

D'Artagnan threw the dice trembling and rolled the number three; his pallor frightened Athos, who contented himself with saying:

"That is a sorry throw, comrade; you shall have the horses fully harnessed, monsieur."

The triumphant Englishman did not even take the trouble to shake the dice; he threw them on the table without looking, so sure was he of victory. D'Artagnan had turned away to hide his ill humor.

“Well, well, well!” said Athos in his calm voice. “That throw of the dice is extraordinary; I have seen it only four times in my life: two aces!”

The Englishman looked and was struck with astonishment; d’Artagnan looked and blushed with pleasure.

“Yes,” continued Athos, “only four times: once at M. de Créquy’s; another time at my own house in the country, in my château at *****, when I had a château; a third time at M. de Tréville’s, where it surprised us all; and finally a fourth time at a tavern, where it fell to me, and where I lost a hundred louis on it and a supper.”

“Monsieur takes back his horse,” said the Englishman.

“Certainly!” said d’Artagnan.

“Then there is no return match?”

“Our conditions said: No return match; you remember.”

“True; the horse is to be returned to your lackey, monsieur.”

“One moment,” said Athos. “With your permission, monsieur, I ask to say a word to my friend.”

“Say it.”

Athos drew d’Artagnan aside.

“Well!” d’Artagnan said to him, “what do you want with me now, tempter? You want me to play, don’t you?”

“No, I want you to reflect.”

“On what?”

“You are going to take back the horse?”

“No doubt.”

“You are wrong; I would take the hundred pistoles; you know you staked the harness against the horse, or a hundred pistoles, at your choice.”

“Yes.”

“I would take the hundred pistoles.”

“Well, I take the horse.”

“And you are wrong, I repeat. What shall we do with one horse between the two of us? I cannot ride pillion; we would look like the two sons of Aymon who had lost their brother; you cannot humiliate me by riding beside me on that magnificent steed. For my part, without hesitating a single instant, I would take the hundred pistoles; we need money to get back to Paris.”

“I am set on that horse, Athos.”

“And you are wrong, my friend; a horse shies, my friend, a horse stumbles and founders, a horse eats from a rack where a glandered horse has eaten—there goes a horse, or rather a hundred pistoles lost; and then the master must feed his horse, whereas, on the contrary, a hundred pistoles feed their master.”

“But how shall we get back?”

“On our lackeys’ horses, by God! Our faces will always show plainly enough that we are men of condition.”

“A fine figure we shall cut on nags, while Aramis and Porthos ride on their horses!”

“Aramis! Porthos!” cried Athos, and he began to laugh.

“What?” asked d’Artagnan, who understood nothing of his friend’s hilarity.

“Nothing, nothing. Continue,” said Athos.

“So, your advice?”

“Is to take the hundred pistoles, d’Artagnan; with the hundred pistoles we will feast until the end of the month; we have undergone fatigues, you see, and it will be good to rest a little.”

“Rest? Oh, no, Athos; as soon as we are in Paris, I set about searching for that poor woman.”

“Well! do you believe your horse will be as useful to you for that as good gold louis? Take the hundred pistoles, my friend, take the hundred pistoles.”

D’Artagnan needed only a reason to give in; that one seemed excellent to him. Besides, by resisting longer, he feared he would appear selfish in Athos’s eyes. He therefore accepted and chose the hundred pistoles, which the Englishman counted out to him on the spot.

Then they thought only of leaving. The peace concluded with the innkeeper, in addition to Athos’s old horse, cost six pistoles. D’Artagnan and Athos took Planchet’s and Grimaud’s horses; the two lackeys set out on foot, carrying the saddles on their heads.

However badly mounted the two friends were, they soon outstripped their lackeys and arrived at Crèvecoeur. From afar they caught sight of Aramis, leaning mournfully at his window and watching, like Sister Anne, the sun turn to dust and the horizon turn green.

“Halloa! hey! Aramis! what the devil are you doing there?” cried the two friends. “Ah! it is you, d’Artagnan? it is you, Athos?” said the young man. “I was musing on the swiftness with which the goods of this world pass away: my English horse, which was going away and has just disappeared amid a whirlwind of dust, was to me a living image of the frailty of earthly things. Life itself can be resolved into three words: Erit, est, fuit.”

“Which means, at bottom...” asked d’Artagnan, who was beginning to suspect the truth.

“It means that I have just made a fool’s bargain. Sixty louis for a horse which, from the way he runs, can do five leagues an hour at a trot.”

D’Artagnan and Athos burst out laughing.

“My dear d’Artagnan,” said Aramis, “do not bear me too much ill will, I beg you; necessity knows no law. Besides, I am the first punished, since that infamous horse dealer has robbed me of at least fifty louis. Ah! you are careful managers, you others; you come on your lackeys’ horses, and you have your fine horses led by hand, gently and by short stages.”

At that same instant, a wagon that had for some moments been appearing on the road from Amiens stopped, and Grimaud and Planchet were seen getting out of it with their saddles on their heads. The wagon was returning empty to Paris, and the two lackeys had engaged, in exchange for their transport, to keep the carter’s thirst quenched all along the road.

“What is that?” said Aramis, seeing what was going on. “Nothing but the saddles?”

“Do you understand now?” said Athos.

“My friends, it is exactly the same with me. I kept the harness by instinct. Halloa, Bazin, carry my new harness over beside those of these gentlemen.”

“And what have you done with your doctors?” asked d’Artagnan.

“My dear fellow, I invited them to dinner the next day,” said Aramis; “there is exquisite wine here, let it be said in passing; I made them drunk as best I could; then the curé forbade me to leave the cassock, and the Jesuit begged me to have him received as a musketeer!”“Without a thesis?” cried d’Artagnan, “without a thesis? I demand the suppression of the thesis!”

“Since then,” continued Aramis, “I live agreeably. I have begun a poem in one-syllable lines; it is rather difficult, but merit in all things lies in difficulty. The subject is gallant; I will read you the first canto; it has four hundred lines and lasts a minute.”

— Upon my word, my dear Aramis, said d'Artagnan, who detested verse almost as much as he did Latin, add to the merit of difficulty that of brevity, and you may at least be sure that your poem will have two merits.

— Then, continued Aramis, it breathes honest passions, you will see. Well now! my friends, we are returning to Paris, are we not? Bravo, I am ready! We shall therefore find that good Porthos again? so much the better! You do not believe that I missed him, that great simpleton? I like to see him pleased with himself, that reconciles me with him. He is not the man to have sold his horse, even for a kingdom; I should like to see him already on his beast and on his saddle. He will have, I am sure, the air of the Great Mogul.

They halted for an hour to let the horses breathe; Aramis settled his account, placed Bazin in the wagon with his comrades, and they set out to rejoin Porthos.

They found him almost cured and consequently less pale than d'Artagnan had seen him on his first visit, and seated before a table where, although he was alone, was spread a dinner for four persons. This dinner consisted of meats gallantly trussed, choice wines, and superb fruits.

— Ah! by heaven, said he, rising, you arrive marvelously well, gentlemen: I was just at the soup, and you are going to dine with me.

— Oh! oh! said d'Artagnan, it is not Mousqueton who has lassoed such bottles as those; and then there is a larded fricandeau and a fillet of beef...

— I am recovering, said Porthos, I am recovering. Nothing weakens one like those devilish sprains. Have you had sprains, Athos?

— Never; only, I remember that in our scuffle in the Rue Férou I received a sword thrust which, at the end of fifteen or eighteen days, had produced on me exactly the same effect as your sprain, Porthos.

— But this dinner was not for you alone, my dear Porthos? asked Aramis.

— No, said Porthos, I was expecting a few gentlemen of the neighborhood who sent me word a while ago that they would not come; you will replace them, and I shall not lose by the exchange. Hallo! Mousqueton! chairs! and let the bottles be doubled.

"Do you know what we are eating here?" said Athos, after about ten minutes.

"By Jove!" replied d'Artagnan, "for my part I am eating veal garnished with thistles and marrow."

"And I am eating lamb cutlets," said Porthos.

"And I," said Aramis, "am eating a breast of chicken."

"You are all mistaken, gentlemen," answered Athos gravely; "you are eating horse."

"Come now," said d'Artagnan.

"Horse!" said Aramis, with a grimace of disgust.

Porthos alone made no reply.

"Yes, horse; isn't it so, Porthos, that we are eating horse? Perhaps even the caparisons with it!"

"No, gentlemen; I kept the harness," said Porthos.

"Faith, we are all alike," said Aramis; "one would think we had agreed on it."

"What would you have?" said Porthos; "that horse was a disgrace to my visitors, and I did not want to humiliate them."

"Besides, your duchess is still at the waters, isn't she?" resumed d'Artagnan.

"Still," replied Porthos. "Well, faith, the governor of the province, one of the gentlemen I was expecting to dinner today, seemed to me to desire it so much that I gave it to him."

"Gave it to him!" cried d'Artagnan.

"Oh! good heavens, yes, gave it to him, that's the word," said Porthos, "for it was certainly worth a hundred and fifty louis, and the miser would only pay me eighty for it."

"Without the saddle," said Aramis.

"Yes, without the saddle."

"You will observe, gentlemen," said Athos, "that it is still Porthos who has made the best bargain of us all."

Then there was a burst of laughter that quite startled poor Porthos; but the reason for this hilarity was soon explained to him, and he joined in it noisily, according to his custom.

"So we are all in funds," said d'Artagnan.

"Not on my account," said Athos. "I found Aramis's Spanish wine so good that I had some sixty bottles loaded into the lackeys' wagon, which left me very short of money."

"And I," said Aramis, "just imagine that I had given away my last penny to the church of Montdidier and to the Jesuits of Amiens, and that I had besides contracted obligations which I had to fulfill: masses ordered for me and for you, gentlemen, which will be said, and from which I have no doubt we shall find ourselves wonderfully benefited."

"And I," said Porthos, "do you think my outfit cost me nothing? Not counting Mousqueton's wound, for which I was obliged to have the surgeon come twice a day."

"Come, come," said Athos, exchanging a smile with d'Artagnan and Aramis, "I see that you have acted generously toward the poor fellow. That is like a good master."

"In short," continued Porthos, "once my expenses are paid, I shall still have some thirty crowns left."

"And I about ten pistoles," said Aramis.

"It seems," said Athos, "that we are the Croesuses of society. How much have you left of your hundred pistoles, d'Artagnan?"

"Of my hundred pistoles? First, I gave you fifty."

"You think so?"

"By Jove!"

"Ah! that's true, I forgot it."

"Then I paid six of them to the host."

"What an animal that host is! Why did you give him six pistoles?"

"It was you who told me to give them to him."

"On my honor! I am too kind. And the remainder?"

"Twenty-five pistoles," said d'Artagnan.

"And I," said Athos, drawing some small change from his pocket, "here it is."

"You, nothing."

"Faith, or so little that it is not worth adding to the total."

"Now, let us calculate how much we possess: Porthos?"

"Thirty crowns."

"Aramis?"

"Ten pistoles."

"And you, d'Artagnan?"

"Twenty-five."

"That makes in all?" said Athos.

"Four hundred and seventy-five livres," said d'Artagnan, who calculated like Archimedes.

"Once in Paris, we shall still have a good four hundred," said Porthos, "plus the harnesses."

"But what about our squadron horses?" said Aramis.

"Well! out of the four horses of our lackeys we will make two for the masters, to be drawn by lot; with the four hundred livres we will make half of one more for one of the dismounted men, then we will give the gratuities from our pockets to d'Artagnan, who has a good hand, and who will go and play them at the first gaming house he comes to. There!"

"Let us dine, then," said Porthos, "for the second course is getting cold."

And the four friends, henceforth more at ease about their future, did honor to the meal, the remains of which were left to Messieurs Mousqueton, Bazin, Planchet, and Grimaud.

On arriving in Paris, d'Artagnan found a letter from M. de Tréville, who warned him that, His Majesty's firmly settled intention being to open the campaign on the first of May, he must forthwith prepare his equipments.

He ran at once to his comrades, whom he had just left half an hour before, and whom he found very sad or rather very preoccupied. They were holding a council at Athos's, which always indicated circumstances of a certain gravity.

Indeed, they had just received, each at his own lodging, a similar letter from M. de Tréville.

The four philosophers looked at one another quite stupefied; M. de Tréville did not joke where discipline was concerned. It was especially the equipments that embarrassed them.

"And how much do you estimate these equipments at?" said d'Artagnan.

"Oh! there is no use denying it," replied Aramis, "we have just made our calculations, with a Spartan stinginess, and we need fifteen hundred livres each."

"Four times fifteen makes sixty, that is six thousand livres," said Athos.

— "I, for my part," said d'Artagnan, "it seems to me that a thousand livres would be enough for each of us. It is true that I am not speaking as a Spartan, but as a procurator...."

That word procurator awakened Porthos.

— "Hold on! I have an idea," said he.

— "That is already something; as for me, I do not have even the shadow of one," said Athos coldly; "but as for d'Artagnan, gentlemen, he is truly mad. A thousand livres! I declare that for my own equipment alone I need two thousand."

“Four times two is eight,” said Aramis then; “so we need eight thousand livres for our equipment, though it is true we already have the saddles.”