Skip to main content
Les Trois MousquetairesAlexandre Dumas

MEN OF THE ROBE AND MEN OF THE SWORD.

On the day after the events just related had taken place, Athos not having reappeared, M. de Tréville was informed by d'Artagnan and Porthos of his disappearance.

As for Aramis, he had asked for five days' leave, and was at Rouen, it was said, on family business.

M. de Tréville was the father of his soldiers. The least and most unknown among them, as soon as he wore the uniform of the company, was as certain of his aid and support as his own brother could have been.

He therefore went at once to the lieutenant criminal. The officer commandingthe post of the Croix-Rouge was sent for, and the successive information received showed that Athos was temporarily lodged at Fort-l'Évêque.

Athos had passed through all the trials which we have seen Bonacieux undergo.

We have witnessed the scene of confrontation between the two captives. Athos (who had said nothing until then, for fear that d'Artagnan, worried in his turn, might not have the time he needed, Athos declared from that moment that his name was Athos and not d'Artagnan.

He added that he knew neither M. nor Mme Bonacieux; that he had never spoken to either of them; that he had come at about ten o'clock in the evening to pay a visit to M. d'Artagnan, his friend, but that until that hour he had remained at M. de Tréville's, where he had dined; twenty witnesses, he added, could attest the fact, and he named several distinguished gentlemen, among others M. le duc de la Trémouille.

The second commissioner was as stunned as the first by the simple and firm declaration of this musketeer, on whom he would gladly have taken the revenge that men of the robe so love to win over men of the sword; but the name of M. de Tréville and that of M. le duc de la Trémoille deserved consideration.

Athos was also sent to the cardinal, but unfortunately the cardinal was at the Louvre with the king.

It was precisely the moment when M. de Tréville, having left the house of the criminal lieutenant and that of the governor of the Fort-l'Évêque, without having been able to find Athos, arrived at His Majesty's.

As captain of the musketeers, M. de Tréville had the right of entry to the king at all hours.

Everyone knows what the king's prejudices against the queen were, prejudices skillfully kept up by the cardinal, who, in the matter of intrigues, distrusted women infinitely more than men. One of the great causes of this prejudice especially was Anne of Austria's friendship for Mme de Chevreuse. These two women worried him more than the wars with the Spaniard, the quarrels with England, and the embarrassment of the finances. In his eyes and in his conviction, Mme de Chevreuse served the queen not only in her political intrigues, but, what tormented him still more, in her love intrigues.

At the first word of what M. le Cardinal had said—that Mme de Chevreuse, exiled to Tours, and believed to be in that city, had come to Paris, and, during the five days she had stayed there, had thrown the police off her track—the king had flown into a furious rage. Capricious and unfaithful, the king wished to be called Louis the Just and Louis the Chaste. Posterity will with difficulty understand this character, which history explains only by facts and never by reasoning.

But when the cardinal added that not only had Mme de Chevreuse come to Paris, but that the queen had renewed relations with her by means of one of those mysterious correspondences which at that time were called a cabal; when he affirmed that he, the cardinal, was about to unravel the most obscure threads of this intrigue; when, at the moment of arresting in the act, in flagrante delicto, furnished with all the proofs, the queen's emissary near the exile, a musketeer had dared to interrupt violently the course of justice by falling sword in hand upon honest men of the law charged with examining the whole affair impartially in order to place it before the king's eyes, Louis XIII could contain himself no longer; he took a step toward the queen's apartments with that pale and mute indignation which, when it burst forth, drove this prince to the coldest cruelty.

And yet in all this the cardinal had not yet said a word of the Duke of Buckingham.

It was then that M. de Tréville entered, cold, polite, and in irreproachable attire.

Warned of what had just taken place by the presence of the cardinal and by the alteration in the king's face, M. de Tréville felt strong as Samson before the Philistines.

Louis XIII was already placing his hand on the door knob; at the noise M. de Tréville made on entering, he turned around.

"You arrive at the right moment, monsieur," said the king, who, when his passions had risen to a certain pitch, did not know how to dissemble, "and I am learning fine things about your musketeers."

"And I," said M. de Tréville coldly, "have fine things to teach Your Majesty about your men of the robe."

"I beg your pardon!" said the king haughtily.

"I have the honor to inform Your Majesty," continued Tréville in the same tone, "that a party of procurators, commissioners, and police agents, very estimable people, but very bitter, it appears, against the uniform, have taken it upon themselves to arrest in a house, to carry off in the open street, and to throw into the Fort-l'Évêque, all this on an order they refused to show me, one of my musketeers, or rather one of yours, Sire, of irreproachable conduct, of an almost illustrious reputation, and whom Your Majesty knows favorably, M. Athos."

"Athos," said the king mechanically; "yes, upon my word, I know that name."

"Let Your Majesty recall it," said M. de Tréville; "M. Athos is that musketeer who, in the unfortunate duel you know of, had the misfortune to wound M. Calusac severely. — By the way, monseigneur," continued Tréville, addressing the cardinal, "M. de Calusac is quite recovered, is he not?"

"Thank you," said the cardinal, pursing his lips with anger.

"M. Athos, then, had gone to pay a visit to one of his friends then absent," continued M. de Tréville, "to a young Béarnais, cadet in His Majesty's guards, in the Essarts company; but scarcely had he installed himself at his friend's and taken up a book while waiting for him, when a cloud of recers and soldiers mingled together came to lay siege to the house, burst open several doors..."

The cardinal made the king a sign that meant: "It is about the affair I spoke to you of."

"We know all that," replied the king, "for all that was done for our service."

"Then," said Tréville, "it was also for Your Majesty's service that one of my innocent musketeers was seized, placed between two guards like a malefactor, and paraded through the midst of an insolent populace—this gallant man, who has shed his blood ten times for the service of Your Majesty and is ready to shed it again."

"Bah!" said the king, shaken; "did things happen thus?"

"M. de Tréville does not say," resumed the cardinal with the greatest phlegm, "that this innocent musketeer, this gallant man, had, an hour earlier, just struck with sword blows four instructing commissioners delegated by me to investigate an affair of the highest importance."

"I defy Your Eminence to prove it," cried M. de Tréville with his wholly Gascon frankness and his wholly military bluntness; "for, an hour earlier, M. Athos, who, I will confide to Your Majesty, is a man of the highest quality, did me the honor, after having dined at my house, of conversing in the drawing room of my mansion with M. le duc de la Trémouille and M. le comte de Châlus, who were there."

The king looked at the cardinal.

"A report is proof," said the cardinal, replying aloud to His Majesty's mute interrogation, "and the maltreated men have drawn up the following, which I have the honor to present to Your Majesty."

"Is the report of men of the robe worth the word of honor," replied Tréville proudly, "the honor of the sword?"

"Come, come, Tréville, be silent," said the king.

"If His Eminence has any suspicions against one of my musketeers," said Tréville, "M. le cardinal's justice is well enough known that I myself demand an inquiry."

"In the house where this descent of justice was made," continued the cardinal impassibly, "there lodges, I believe, a Béarnais friend of the musketeer."

"Your Eminence means M. d'Artagnan."

"I mean a young man whom you protect, M. de Tréville."

"Yes, Your Eminence, that is exactly it."

—Do you not suspect this young man of having given bad advice...

—To M. Athos, to a man twice his age? interrupted M. de Tréville; no, monseigneur. Besides, M. d'Artagnan spent the evening at my house.

—Well now, said the cardinal, so everyone spent the evening at your house?

—Would His Eminence doubt my word? said Tréville, the red of anger on his brow.

—No, God forbid! said the cardinal; but only, at what time was he at your house?

—Oh! that, I can tell Your Eminence knowingly; for, as he was coming in, I noticed that it was half past nine by the clock, although I had thought it was later.

—And at what time did he leave your house?

—At half past ten, exactly one hour after the event.

—But after all, replied the cardinal, who did not for a moment suspect Tréville's loyalty, and who felt that victory was slipping from him, but after all, M. Athos was arrested in that house in the rue des Fossoyeurs.

—Is a friend forbidden to visit a friend, is a musketeer of my company forbidden to fraternize with a guard of M. des Essarts's company?

—Yes, when the house in which he fraternizes with that friend is suspect.

—The fact is, that house is suspect, Tréville, said the king; perhaps you do not know it?

—Indeed, Sire, I was unaware of it. In any case, it may be suspect throughout; but I deny that it is so in the part where M. d'Artagnan lives; for I can assure you, Sire, that, if I am to believe what he said, there does not exist a more devoted servant of His Majesty, a more profound admirer of M. the cardinal.

“Was it not this d’Artagnan who one day wounded Jussac in that unfortunate encounter which took place near the Carmelite convent of the Discalced?” asked the king, looking at the cardinal, who flushed with vexation.

“And the next day, Bernajoux. Yes, Sire; yes, that is quite right, and Your Majesty has a good memory.”

“Come, what are we to decide?” said the king.

“That concerns Your Majesty more than me,” said the cardinal. “I would affirm his guilt.”

“And I deny it,” said Tréville. “But His Majesty has judges, and those judges will decide.”

“That is it,” said the king, “let us refer the case to the judges; it is their business to judge, and they will judge.”“Only,” resumed Tréville, “it is very sad that in these unhappy times in which we live, the purest life and the most unquestionable virtue do not exempt a man from infamy and persecution. So the army will be little satisfied, I can answer for it, at being exposed to harsh treatment over matters of police.”

The word was imprudent, but Tréville had launched it with full knowledge of what he was doing. He wanted an explosion, because in that the mine makes fire, and fire gives light.

“Matters of police!” cried the king, taking up M. Tréville’s words; “matters of police! and what do you know about them, monsieur? Meddle with your musketeers and do not break my head. It seems, to hear you, that if by misfortune a musketeer were arrested, France would be in danger. Eh! what a fuss for a musketeer! I will have ten arrested, ventrebleu! a hundred even... the whole company... and I do not want anyone to breathe a word of it.”

“From the moment they are suspect to Your Majesty,” said Tréville, “the musketeers are guilty; so you see me, Sire, ready to return my sword to you, for after having accused my soldiers, M. the cardinal, I do not doubt, will end by accusing me myself; so it is better that I constitute myself a prisoner with M. Athos, who is already arrested, and M. d’Artagnan, who will doubtless be arrested.”

“Gascon head, will you have done?” said the king.

“Sire,” replied Tréville, without lowering his voice in the least, “order that my musketeer be returned to me, or that he be tried.”

“He shall be tried,” said the cardinal.

“Well! so much the better, for in that case I shall ask His Majesty’s permission to plead for him.”

The king feared a scene.

“If His Eminence,” he said, “had not personally motives...”

The cardinal saw the king coming and went to meet him.

“Pardon,” he said; “but from the moment Your Majesty sees in me a prejudiced judge, I withdraw.”

“Come,” said the king, “do you swear to me by my father that M. Athos was at your house during the event and that he took no part in it?”

“By your glorious father and by yourself, who are what I love and venerate most in the world, I swear it!”

“Be pleased to reflect, Sire,” said the cardinal; “if we release the prisoner thus, we shall no longer be able to discover the truth.”

“M. Athos will always be there,” resumed M. de Tréville, “ready to answer when it pleases the men of the robe to interrogate him; he will not desert, M. the cardinal; be at ease; I answer for him, I do.”

“In fact, he will not desert,” said the king. “He will always be found, as M. de Tréville says. Besides,” he added in a lower voice and looking at His Eminence with a suppliant air, “let us give them some sense of security; that is politics.”

This policy of Louis XIII made Richelieu smile.

“Order it, Sire,” he said, “you have the right of pardon.”

“The right of pardon applies only to the guilty,” said Tréville, who wanted to have the last word, and my musketeer is innocent. It is therefore not pardon that you are about to grant, Sire, it is justice.”

“And he is at the Fort-l’Évêque?” said the king.

“Yes, Sire, and in solitary confinement, in a dungeon, like the worst of criminals.”

“Devil! devil!” murmured the king, “what is to be done?”

“Sign the order for his release, and all will be settled,” resumed the cardinal; “I believe, like Your Majesty, that M. de Tréville’s guarantee is more than sufficient.”

Tréville bowed respectfully with a joy that was not unmixed with fear; he would have preferred a stubborn resistance from the cardinal to this sudden facility.

The king signed the order for release, and Tréville carried it away without delay.

As he was about to go out, the cardinal gave him a friendly smile and said to the king:

“A good harmony reigns between the chiefs and the soldiers among your musketeers, Sire; that is very profitable for the service and very honorable for all.”

“He will play me some bad turn presently,” said Tréville; “one never has the last word with such a man. But let us make haste, for the king may change his mind at any moment; and, after all, it is more difficult to put back into the Bastille or the Fort-l’Évêque a man who has come out of it than to keep there a prisoner one holds there.”

M. de Tréville made a triumphant entry into the Fort-l’Évêque, where he delivered the musketeer, whom his peaceful indifference had not abandoned.

Then, the first time he saw d’Artagnan again: “You had a narrow escape,” he said to him; “there is your sword thrust at Jussac paid for. There still remains that of Bernajoux, but you must not rely too much on that.”

Besides, M. de Tréville was right to distrust the cardinal and to think that all was not over, for scarcely had the captain of the musketeers closed the door behind him than His Eminence said to the king:

“Now that we are alone, we will talk seriously, if it pleases Your Majesty.... Sire, M. de Buckingham has been in Paris for five days and left only this morning.”