About this book
Emma marries a country doctor, cannot bear provincial life, and chases the passion she only read about. Flaubert's 1857 novel, free to read online.
XI
He had lately read the praise of a new method for the cure of clubfeet; and, as he was a partisan of progress, he conceived this patriotic idea that Yonville, to keep up with the times, ought to have operations of strephopody.
For, he said to Emma, what does one risk? Consider (and he enumerated on his fingers the advantages of the attempt): success almost certain, relief and improvement of the patient, celebrity quickly acquired by the operator. Why, for instance, should not your husband want to rid poor Hippolyte of the Lion d'or of it? Note that he would not fail to relate his cure to all the travelers, and then (Homais lowered his voice and looked around him) who, then, would prevent me from sending a little note about it to the newspaper? Eh! my God! an article circulates..., people talk about it..., it ends by making a snowball! And who knows? who knows?
Indeed, Bovary might succeed; nothing assured Emma that he was not skilful, and what satisfaction for her to have urged him to a step from which his reputation and his fortune would be increased!
She asked only to lean upon something more solid than love.
Charles, urged by the apothecary and by her, allowed himself to be convinced. He sent for Dr. Duval's volume from Rouen, and every evening, taking his head in his hands, he buried himself in this reading.
While he was studying the equinus, the varus, and the valgus, that is to say, strephocatopodia, strephendopodia, and strephexopodia (or, to speak more plainly, the different deviations of the foot, whether downward, inward, or outward), with strephypopodia and strephanopodia (in other words, torsion downward and straightening upward), M. Homais, by all sorts of arguments, was exhorting the stable-boy to have the operation performed.
"You will perhaps hardly feel a slight pain; it is a simple prick like a little bleeding, less than the extraction of certain corns."
Hippolyte, reflecting, rolled his stupid eyes.
"Besides," resumed the druggist, "it is no concern of mine! it is for your sake! out of pure humanity! I should like to see you, my friend, rid of your hideous limp, with that swaying of the lumbar region, which, although you may deny it, must be considerably injurious to you in the exercise of your trade."
Then Homais represented to him how much more brisk and nimble he would feel afterward, and even gave him to understand that he would be all the better for pleasing the women, and the stable-man began to smile heavily. Then he attacked him through his vanity:
"Are you not a man, hang it all? What would it be,then, if you had had to serve, to go and fight under the colors?... Ah! Hippolyte!"
And Homais went away, declaring that he could not understand this obstinacy, this blindness in refusing the benefits of science.
The unfortunate man yielded, for it was like a conspiracy. Binet, who never meddled in other people's affairs, Madame Lefrançois, Artémise, the neighbors, and even the mayor, M. Tuvache, everyone urged him, lectured him, made him ashamed; but what finally decided him was that it would cost him nothing. Bovary even undertook to furnish the machine for the operation. Emma had had the idea of this generosity; and Charles consented to it, saying in the bottom of his heart that his wife was an angel.
With the advice of the druggist, and starting over three times, he therefore had constructed by the carpenter, aided by the locksmith, a sort of box weighing about eight pounds, in which iron, wood, sheet-iron, leather, screws, and nuts were by no means spared.
However, in order to know which tendon to cut in Hippolyte, it was first necessary to know what species of clubfoot he had.
He had a foot forming an almost straight line with the leg, which did not prevent it from being turned inward, so that it was an equinus combined with a little varus, or rather a slight varus strongly marked with equinus. But with this equinus, broad indeed as a horse's foot, with rough skin, dry tendons, large toes, and where the black nails figuredthe nails of a horseshoe, the strephopod, from morning till night, galloped like a stag. He was continually seen in the square, skipping around the carts, throwing forward his uneven support. He even seemed more vigorous in that leg than in the other. From having served so much, it had contracted, as it were, moral qualities of patience and energy, and when he was given some heavy task, he hurried along on it, preferably.
Now, since it was an equinus, the Achilles tendon had to be cut, at the risk of attacking the anterior tibial muscle later to get rid of the varus; for the doctor did not dare risk two operations at one stroke, and he was already trembling with the fear of attacking some important region with which he was unacquainted.
Neither Ambroise Paré, applying for the first time since Celsus, after fifteen centuries' interval, the immediate ligature of an artery; nor Dupuytren going to open an abscess through a thick layer of brain; nor Gensoul, when he performed the first ablation of the upper maxilla, had certainly so throbbing a heart, so trembling a hand, so strained an intellect as M. Bovary when he approached Hippolyte, his tenotome between his fingers. And, as in hospitals, there was seen beside him on a table a heap of lint, waxed threads, many bandages, a pyramid of bandages, all the bandages there were at the apothecary's. It was M. Homais who had organized all these preparations since morning, as much to dazzle the multitude as to deceive himself. Charlespricked the skin; a dry crack was heard. The tendon was cut, the operation was over. Hippolyte could not get over his surprise; he leaned over Bovary's hands to cover them with kisses.
"Come, calm yourself," said the apothecary, "you will show your gratitude to your benefactor later!"
And he went down to tell the result to five or six curious persons who were standing about in the yard, and who imagined that Hippolyte would reappear walking straight. Then Charles, having buckled his patient into the mechanical contrivance, returned home, where Emma, full of anxiety, was waiting for him at the door. She jumped on his neck; they sat down to table; he ate a great deal, and even wished, at dessert, to take a cup of coffee, a debauch which he allowed himself only on Sundays when there were guests.
The evening was charming, full of conversation, of dreams in common. They spoke of their future fortune, of improvements to be introduced into their household; he saw his consideration extending, his well-being increasing, his wife always loving him; and she found herself happy to refresh herself in a new sentiment, healthier, better, in short to feel some tenderness for this poor fellow who cherished her. The idea of Rodolphe, for a moment, passed through her head; but her eyes returned to Charles; she even remarked with surprise that he had not ugly teeth.
They were in bed when M. Homais, in spite of the cook, suddenly entered the room,holding in his hand a freshly written sheet of paper. It was the advertisement he destined for the Fanal de Rouen. He brought it to them to read.
"Read it yourself," said Bovary.
He read:
"Despite the prejudices which still cover a part of the face of Europe like a net, light is nevertheless beginning to penetrate into our countryside. Thus, on Tuesday, our little town of Yonville saw itself the theater of a surgical experiment which is at the same time an act of high philanthropy. M. Bovary, one of our most distinguished practitioners..."
"Ah! it is too much! too much!" said Charles, suffocated by emotion.
"But no, not at all! how so!... 'Has operated on a clubfoot...' I did not put the scientific term, because, you know, in a newspaper... everyone perhaps would not understand; the masses must..."
"Indeed," said Bovary. "Continue."
“I resume,” said the druggist. “Monsieur Bovary, one of our most distinguished practitioners, has operated on a clubfoot upon one Hippolyte Tautain, stable-boy for the last twenty-five years at the Hôtel du Lion d’Or, kept by Widow Lefrançois, on the Place d’Armes. The novelty of the attempt and the interest attaching to the subject had attracted such a crowd that there was a veritable congestion at the threshold of the establishment. The operation, moreover, was performed as if by enchantment, and scarcely a few dropsof blood came to the skin, as if to say that the rebellious tendon had at last yielded under the efforts of art. The patient, strange to say (we affirm it from ocular evidence), did not complain of any pain. His condition, up to the present, leaves nothing to be desired. Everything leads us to believe that the convalescence will be short; and who knows even if, at the next village festival, we shall not see our brave Hippolyte figuring in bacchic dances, amid a chorus of jovial fellows, and thus proving to all eyes, by his verve and his entrechats, his complete recovery? Honour, then, to the generous scientists! honour to those indefatigable spirits who consecrate their vigils to the amelioration or to the alleviation of their kind! Honour! thrice honour! Is this not the occasion to exclaim that the blind shall see, the deaf shall hear, and the lame shall walk. But what fanaticism formerly promised to its elect, science now accomplishes for all men! We shall keep our readers informed of the successive phases of this remarkable cure.”
This did not prevent Mother Lefrançois, five days later, from arriving all scared, crying:
“Help! he is dying!... I am losing my head!”
Charles rushed to the Lion d’Or, and the druggist, who caught sight of him passing across the square without a hat, abandoned the pharmacy. He appeared himself, panting, red, anxious, and asking everyone who was going up the stairs:
“What is the matter with our interesting stræ thopode?”
He was writhing, the stræ thopode, in atrocious convulsions, so much so that the mechanical motor in which his leg was enclosed struck against the wall hard enough to break it in. With great precautions, so as not to disturb the position of the limb, the box was therefore removed, and a frightful spectacle was seen. The forms of the foot disappeared in such a swelling that the whole skin seemed about to burst, and it was covered with ecchymoses caused by the famous machine. Hippolyte had already complained of suffering from it; no attention had been paid to it; it had to be acknowledged that he had not been entirely wrong, and he was left free for a few hours. But scarcely had the œdema a little disappeared when the two scientists thought it proper to restore the limb to the apparatus, and to tighten it there more, to hasten matters. Finally, three days later, Hippolyte could bear it no longer, and they again removed the mechanism, much astonished at the result they perceived. A livid tumefaction spread over the leg, with blisters here and there, whence oozed a black liquid. This was taking a serious turn. Hippolyte began to be bored, and Mother Lefrançois installed him in the little room near the kitchen, so that he might at least have some distraction.
.
But the tax collector, who dined there every day, complained bitterly of such a neighbor. So Hippolyte was moved into the billiard room.
He lay there, moaning beneath his heavy blankets, pale, with a long beard and hollow eyes, and from time to time turning his sweating head on the dirty pillow where the flies settled. Madame Bovary came to see him. She brought him cloths for his poultices, and comforted and encouraged him. Besides, he did not lack company, especially on market days, when the peasants around him pushed the billiard balls, plied their cues, smoked, drank, sang, and bawled.
"How goes it?" they would say, slapping him on the shoulder. "Ah! you're not so proud, it seems! But it's your own fault. You should do this, do that."
And they told him stories of people who had all been cured by remedies other than his; then, by way of consolation, they added:
"It's because you pamper yourself too much! Get up, then! You coddle yourself like a king! Ah! no matter, you old rascal! you don't smell good!"
The gangrene, indeed, was spreading more and more. Bovary himself was sick over it. He came at every hour, at every moment. Hippolyte looked at him with eyes full of terror and stammered, sobbing:
"When shall I be cured?... Ah! save me!... How unhappy I am! how unhappy I am!"
And the doctor went away, always recommending a strict diet.
"Don't listen to him, my boy," Mother Lefrançois would say; "they've martyred you quite enough already! you'll only weaken yourself further. Here, swallow this!"
And she offered him some good broth, some slice of leg of mutton, some piece of bacon, and sometimes little glasses of brandy, which he did not have the courage to raise to his lips.
Abbé Bournisien, learning that he was growing worse, asked to see him. He began by pitying him for his illness, while declaring that he ought to rejoice in it, since it was the will of the Lord, and to profit quickly from the occasion to be reconciled with heaven.
"For," said the ecclesiastic in a fatherly tone, "you were somewhat neglecting your duties; you were rarely seen at divine service; how many years is it since you last approached the holy table? I understand that your occupations, that the whirl of the world may have turned you away from the care of your salvation. But now is the hour to think of it. Do not despair, however; I have known great sinners who, close to appearing before God (you are not yet at that point, I know well), had implored His mercy, and who certainly died in the best dispositions. Let us hope that, just like them, you will give us good examples! Thus, by way of precaution, who would prevent you from reciting morning and evening a 'Hail Mary, full of grace' and an 'Our Father, who art in heaven'? Yes, do that! for me, to oblige me. What does it cost?... Do you promise me?"
The poor devil promised. The curate came back on the following days. He chatted with the innkeeper and even told anecdotes interspersed with jokes and puns that Hippolyte did not understand. Then, as soon as circumstances allowed, he returned to matters of religion, assuming a suitable expression.
His zeal appeared to succeed; for soon the clubfooted man showed a desire to go on a pilgrimage to Bon-Secours, if he were cured: to which M. Bournisien replied that he saw no objection; two precautions were better than one. There was no risk.
.
The apothecary was indignant at what he called the priest's maneuvers; they were harmful, he claimed, to Hippolyte's convalescence, and he repeated to Madame Lefrançois:
"Leave him alone! leave him alone! you're unsettling his mind with your mysticism!"
But the good woman would no longer listen to him. He was the cause of everything. Out of a spirit of contradiction, she even hung at the sick man's bedside a holy-water stoup, quite full, with a sprig of boxwood.
Meanwhile religion, no more than surgery, appeared to succor him, and the invincible putrefaction kept climbing always from the extremities toward the belly. In vain did they vary the potions and change the poultices; each day the muscles detached themselves more, and at last Charles answered with an affirmative nod of the head when Mother Lefrançois asked him whether she could not, in desperation, send for M. Canivet of Neufchâtel, who was a celebrity.
A doctor of medicine, fifty years old, enjoying a good position and sure of himself, the colleague did not hesitate to laugh disdainfully when he uncovered that leg gangrened to the knee. Then, having declared flatly that it must be amputated, he went off to the pharmacist's to rant against the asses who could have reduced a wretched man to such a state. Shaking M. Homais by the button of his frock coat, he vociferated in the pharmacy:
"These are Parisian inventions! Those are the ideas of these gentlemen of the Capital! It's the same with strabismus, chloroform, and lithotrity, a heap of monstrosities that the government ought to forbid! But people want to play the clever fellow, and they stuff you with remedies without worrying about the consequences. We are not so strong as that, we others; we are not scholars, marvels, pretty dears; we are practitioners, healers, and we would not dream of operating on someone who is in perfect health! Straighten clubfeet! Can one straighten clubfeet? It's as if one wanted, for example, to make a hunchback straight!"
Homais suffered as he listened to this discourse, and he concealed his discomfort beneath a courtier's smile, having need to spare M. Canivet, whose prescriptions sometimes reached as far as Yonville; so he did not take up Bovary's defense, made not even a single observation, and, abandoning his principles, sacrificed his dignity to the more serious interests of his trade.
This amputation of the thigh by Doctor Canivet was a considerable event in the village! All the inhabitants, that day, had risen earlier, and the Grande-Rue, though full of people, had something lugubrious about it, as if it were a matter of a capital execution. People were discussing Hippolyte's illness at the grocer's; the shops sold nothing, and Madame Tuvache, the mayor's wife, did not stir from her window, so impatient was she to see the operator arrive.
He arrived in his cabriolet, which he drove himself. But, the spring on the right side having in time sagged under the weight of his corpulence, it happened that the carriage leaned a little as it went, and one could see on the other cushion beside him a vast box covered with red sheepskin, whose three brass clasps shone magisterially.
.
When he had entered like a whirlwind beneath the porch of the Lion d'or, the doctor, shouting very loud, ordered his horse unhitched, then went into the stable to see whether it was eating its oats well; for, on arriving at his patients' homes, he occupied himself first with his mare and his cabriolet. People even said on this subject: "Ah! M. Canivet is an original!" And he was esteemed the more for that unshakeable self-assurance. The universe might have perished down to the last man, and he would not have failed in the least of his habits.
Homais presented himself.
"I am counting on you," said the doctor. "Are we ready? Let's go!"
But the apothecary, blushing, confessed that he was too sensitive to attend such an operation.
“When you’re just an onlooker,” he would say, “imagination, you know, it makes an impression! And then my nervous system is so…”
“Ah, come now!” Canivet broke in. “On the contrary, you strike me as prone to apoplexy. And besides, that doesn’t surprise me; for you people, you pharmacists, are continually cooped up in your kitchen, which must end by spoiling your temperament. Look at me, rather: every day I get up at four o’clock, I shave with cold water (I am never cold) and I don’t wear flannel, I never catch a cold, the chest is sound! I live now one way, now another, like a philosopher, at the mercy of the fork. That is why I am not delicate like you, and it is also perfectly all the same to me to cut up a Christian as the first fowl that comes along. After that, you will say, habit…, habit!…”
Then, without any regard for Hippolyte, who was sweating with anguish between his sheets, these gentlemen entered into a conversation in which the apothecary compared the coolness of a surgeon to that of a general; and this comparison was agreeable to Canivet, who poured out words on the demands of his art. He regarded it as a priesthood, although health officers dishonored it. At last, returning to the patient, he examined the bandages brought by Homais, the same ones that had appeared at the time of the clubfoot, and asked for someone to hold the limb for him. Lestiboudois was sent for, and M. Canivet, having rolled up his sleeves, passed into the billiard room, while the apothecary remained with Artémise and the innkeeper, both paler than their apron, their ears strained against the door.
Bovary, meanwhile, did not dare stir from his house. He stayed downstairs in the sitting-room, sitting in the corner of the fireplace without a fire, his chin on his chest, his hands clasped, his eyes fixed. What a misadventure! he thought, what a disappointment! And yet he had taken every imaginable precaution. Fatality had had a hand in it. What did it matter? if Hippolyte later happened to die, it was he who would have murdered him. And then, what reason would he give on his visits, when people questioned him? Perhaps, however, he had made a mistake in something? He searched, and could not find it. But the most famous surgeons were mistaken often enough. That was what people would never be willing to believe! on the contrary, they would laugh, and clap their hands! It would spread as far as Forges! as far as Neufchâtel! as far as Rouen! everywhere! Who knew whether colleagues might not write against him? A controversy would follow, he would have to reply in the newspapers. Hippolyte himself might bring a suit against him. He saw himself dishonoured, ruined, lost! And his imagination, assailed by a multitude of hypotheses, tossed about among them like an empty barrel carried out to sea and rolling on the waves.
.
Emma, facing him, was watching him; she did not share his humiliation, she felt another: it was that of having imagined that such a man could be worth anything, as if twenty times already she had not sufficiently perceived his mediocrity.
Charles was pacing back and forth in the room. His boots creaked on the floor.
— Sit down, she said, you are annoying me!
He sat down again.
How then had she come (she who was so intelligent!) to be mistaken once more? Besides, by what deplorable mania had she thus ruined her existence in continual sacrifices? She recalled all her instincts for luxury, all the privations of her soul, the basenesses of marriage, of housekeeping, her dreams falling in the mud like wounded swallows, all that she had desired, all that she had denied herself, all that she might have had! and why, why?
In the midst of the silence that filled the village, a tearing cry passed through the air. Bovary turned pale enough to faint. She frowned with a nervous gesture, then continued. It was for him, however, for that being, for that man who understood nothing, who felt nothing! for he was there, quite calmly, and without even suspecting that the ridicule of his name would henceforth sully her as it did him. She had made efforts to love him, and she had repented in tears for having yielded to another.
— But perhaps it was a valgus? Bovary suddenly exclaimed, who was pondering.
At the unexpected shock of that phrase falling on her thoughts like a lead bullet on a silver dish, Emma started and raised her head to guess what he meant; and they looked at each other silently, almost stupefied at seeing each other, so far apart were they, in their consciences, from one another. Charles was considering her with the troubled gaze of a drunken man, while, motionless, he listened to the last cries of the amputee, which followed one another in drawn-out modulations, broken by sharp jerks, like the distant howling of some beast being slaughtered. Emma was biting her pale lips, and, rolling between her fingers one of the branches of the polypus she had broken, she fixed on Charles the burning point of her pupils, like two arrows of fire ready to fly. Everything about him now irritated her, his face, his clothes, what he did not say, his whole person, his existence at last. She repented, as of a crime, of her past virtue, and what remained of it was crumbling under the furious blows of her pride. She delighted in all the evil ironies of triumphant adultery. The memory of her lover came back to her with dizzying attractions; she cast her soul into it, carried toward that image by a new enthusiasm; and Charles seemed to her as detached from her life, as absent forever, as impossible and annihilated, as if he were about to die and had been in agony before her eyes.
There was a sound of footsteps on the pavement. Charles looked; and, through the lowered blind, he saw at the edge of the market-halls, in the full sunlight, Doctor Canivet wiping his forehead with his foulard. Homais, behind him, was carrying a large red box in his hand, and both were heading toward the pharmacy.
Then, by a sudden tenderness and discouragement, Charles turned toward his wife and said to her:
— Kiss me, then, my good wife!
— Leave me alone! she said, all red with anger.
— What is the matter? what is the matter? he repeated, stupefied. Calm yourself, pull yourself together!.. You know well that I love you!... come!
— Enough! she cried in a terrible manner.
And escaping from the room, Emma closed the door so hard that the barometer sprang from the wall and smashed on the ground.
Charles sank into his armchair, overwhelmed, seeking what could be the matter with her, imagining a nervous illness, weeping, and vaguely feeling something fatal and incomprehensible circulating around him.
When Rodolphe arrived in the garden that evening, he found his mistress waiting for him at the bottom of the steps, on the first stair. They faded away, and all their rancour melted like snow under the heat of that kiss.