Skip to main content
The OdysseyHomer
About this book

The Cyclops, the Sirens and ten years of detours before Ithaca. Homer's Odyssey in Butcher and Lang's 1883 prose translation, free to read online.

The House of Odysseus.

It is a most difficult thing to understand the arrangements of the hall of Odysseus in which the woors were slaughtered. Let us leave on one side the questions which do not immediately concern us, and follow the movements of Odysseus himself. In Book xvii. 297, he stands by Argos, the dog, which lies nponapoe oupav, 'before the doors;' either the doors which open from the outer court into the public way, or from the house into the outer court. The swineherd then enters the house, and Odysseus soon follows, humbly enough, i'ce 8' eni meAivov ovdov evrooe oupav, 'he sat down on the ashen threshold within the doors.' There Telemachus spied him, and sent him a mess. My impression is, that he was sitting just within the doors of the hall. Probably he looked, from his lowly seat, all the way up to the high table at the upper end, where Telemachus would sit. Now behind Telemachus, behind the high table, were the doors opening on the passages which led to the women's rooms, and to the oaxAuros, or store- chamber where Telemachus had hidden the weapons. We can easily conceive such doors in the wall behind a high table in the hall of a college. The same arrangement of high table, of women's rooms, and of store- chamber may be seen in the plans of the skali, or chief's hall, in Sir G. W. Dasent's Story of Burnt Njal (vol. i. p. c.). These plans should not be neglected by students interested in the architecture of the Homeric age, as the correspondence between the skali and the heroic house is singularly close. Whether in the house of Odysseus a passage ran outside the wall of the hall to the store- chambers, so that a man might go thither from the chief door, without walking through the hall, is not quite certain.

We left Odysseus just within his own door, on the ashen threshold. There he did not remain. On the morning of the day when the wooers were slain, Telemachus purposely (kepoea vavav, xx. 257) called him to another place. Telemachus would sit at the high table, at the upper end of the room. He would face the entrance, and just behind him would be the doors leading to the women's chambers. Here he placed Odysseus, evros evotaeos yeyapov, napd 7divov ovdov, and there Odysseus remained, and thence he shot the wooers. But was this Aavos ovos really at the upper end of the room, where the dais of a college hall is raised? Many things may be taken to point the other way. Let it be observed, however, that λάνος οὐδός was, not improbably, a pretty high dais, faced with stone, above the level of the hall, and on a level with the doors leading to the women's rooms. That it was near the women's rooms, not at the other extremity of the hall, may perhaps be inferred from xxi. 234:—ἀλλὰ σύ, δέΈὔμαιε, φέρον ἀνὰ δώματα τόξον ἐν χείρεσον ἐμοὶ θέμεναι, εἶπεῖν τε γυναιξὶν κληίσαι μεγάροιο θύρας, that is, Odysseus tells Eumaeus to bring the bow to him up to his end of the hall, by the threshold of stone, and then to tell the women (who are close by, inside the door) to make their doors fast. Again, (xxi. 380,) when Odysseus gets the bow, Eumaeus calls Eurycleia out, and bids her shut the door, and to take no heed if she hears a noise of groaning in the halls. Now to tell Eurycleia as much as this, he must have been near her quarters; he could not have shouted from the further end of the hall. The strongest proof, however, that the stone threshold was between the inner chamber and the hall is to be found in xxiii. 88. Penelope comes into the hall, from the inner chambers, ἡ δ' ἐπεὶ εἰσῆλθεν καὶ ὑπέρβη λάινον οὐδόν.

The λάινος οὐδός is also known as that which Agamemnon crossed, when he inquired of the oracle at Pytho, or Delphi; and again, is spoken of in the Iliad as having behind it the countless treasures of Delphi. In both places it may mean the threshold between the nave of the God's house, or hall, and the θαλάμος, or inner chamber of the Pythoness, where she prophesied, and where the treasures were kept, just as in a man's house the women and treasues lay behind the hall. It is certain, at all events, that Odysseus shot from near the stone threshold. His settle was placed near it (xx. 258), from this settle he shot through the iron, and then (xxii. 2), ἀπὸ δ' ἐπὶ μέγαν οὐδόν, 'he leaped on to the great threshold,' and began to slay the wooers. I conceive that the height of the threshold made it a place of strength, and that he had the command of the armoury where the weapons lay, because the door of it was close behind him. Plainly the wooers had not the command of the door giving on the passage to the store chamber or armoury, otherwise they would not have sent Melanthius through the clerestory openings. Now we are never told that this door had been fastened by Eurycleia from within, as the doors leading to the women's chambers had been. Odysseus then showered his arrows from above the high table towards the entrance of the hall. If this is a mistaken view, there must have been more than one 'threshold of stone,' and Telemachus must have reached the armoury by means of a passage running the whole length of the house, from the outer door. In Book xxii. line 76 certainly reads as if Odysseus were guarding the outer door. If he really stood above the high table, then in line 123, ἀκρότατον δὲ παρ' οὖδον, οὖδός (unless, as in the text, we take it to be the threshold of the δροσούρην itself) would be the broad raised place where I have supposed Odysseus to stand. At the edge of it, next the wall, was a postern, guarded by the swineherd, who would indeed have been an 'unenviable swineherd,' as Mr. Buckley calls him, if he had been obliged to guard the postern as it is placed in some plans, that is, at the upper end of the hall among the enemies, while Odysseus is supposed to be at the lower end. There was a shut door behind Odysseus, for (xxii. 258, 275) the spears thrown at him struck it. On the whole, the balance seems somewhat to lean to the theory that Odysseus shot from the οὖδός above the high table, with his back to the store-chamber (with which he could communicate) and to the women's rooms (of which the door was locked), and with his face to the entrance of the hall. On the other hand, the speech of Melanthius (xxii. 136) ἀγχι γὰρ αἰνὶς αὐλῆς καλὰ θύρετρα, is unintelligible on this theory.

The theory of Mr. Watkiss Lloyd (Architect Aug. 4 and 11, 1877) is the same as mine up to the moment when Odysseus ἀλτο ἐπὶ μέγαν οὖδον, where Mr. Watkiss Lloyd supposes that the hero has traversed the whole length of the hall. But it is not in the Homeric manner to leave this important movement unmentioned. as the horses and hounds of Patroclus, and the captive Trojan youths. This last act seems to have been reprobated by the general feeling of Homeric Greece. When the flame had consumed the corpse, the ashes were stored in a golden vase, and that was deposited in a receptacle dug in the floor of the barrow. Last a rounded barrow of stones and earth was built above the dust of the dead, and finally 'a pillar was dragged up thereupon.' (Od. xii. 14.) The στήλη is particularly mentioned in Iliad xvii. 434, 'as a pillar firmly abides that is set on the barrow of woman or man,' and again (Iliad xvi. 457, 675) it is called 'the due of the dead.' These facts suggest two conclusions. First, the famous tombs of the Mycenaean acropolis cannot be of the Homeric age, for they do not conform to Homer's repeated descriptions. Secondly, no antiquarian discovery could be more valuable than that of a real Homeric στήλη. It is most probable that they were not plain stones, but that, as in later Greece, they were engraved with some hieratic and conventional design. The earliest known Greek stelae (leaving those of Mycenae out of the question) were excavated at Sparta. On these are represented two crowned figures, male and female, seated on the same throne, and approached by the much smaller figure of the dead, who bears in his hands a cock, the victim commonly sacrificed after a death by all races from Siberia to Ceylon,—the cock that Socrates 'owed to Asclepius.' The seated figures are doubtless intended for Hades and Persephone. Interesting as these stelae are, they cannot, from the character of the art, be much earlier than the sixth century. If the Mycenaean graves are pre-Homeric, we may suppose that the rude design on the stela, the king fighting from his chariot, is a faint memory of Egyptian art. The discovery of a genuine Homeric tumulus will clear up many archaeological problems. The absence of writing on an ancient memorial pillar would be far from proving that writing was unknown. Uninscribed monoliths have been raised in memory of great events by Scotch Highlanders in the present century. On the subject of the stelae, see Mittelungen der deutschen Archäologischen Institutes in Athen, vol. ii, pp. 20-24.