Across the same 9 test books (121 sampled pages) in an anonymized blind test, PDF Craft scored 78.6–80.0 while Convertio scored 61.0–63.1—a 15.5 to 19.0 point lead for PDF Craft. At the same time, Convertio ran about 15× faster, while Convertio's OCR page pack cost 3.6× to 13× more per 100 pages. The real divide is not occasional OCR typos; it is whether the converter can reassemble recognized text back into a properly structured book.
The full 6-dimension rubric, book list, four-tier scoring scale, and scope limitations are documented in Scanned PDF to EPUB Benchmark: Methodology and PDF Craft Test Results. Below are the head-to-head results from independent blind reviews by Gemini and Deepseek on the same anonymized package.
1. Overall and Dimension Scores
Weighted Overall Score (Original-Language Scanned PDF to EPUB)
| Converter | Gemini Blind Review | Deepseek Blind Review | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| PDF Craft | 78.6 | 80.0 | Both blind reviews agree, ahead by 15.5–19.0 points |
| Convertio | 63.1 | 61.0 | Very fast, but loses heavily on TOC, tables, and formulas |
| Difference (PDF Craft − Convertio) | +15.5 | +19.0 | — |
Average Scores Across All Six Dimensions
| Dimension | Weight | PDF Craft (Gemini / Deepseek) | Convertio (Gemini / Deepseek) | Key Takeaway |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Text Accuracy | 30% | 72.3 / 76.3 | 64.5 / 63.3 | Only an 8–13 point gap; raw text is not the main divide |
| Completeness | 20% | 79.3 / 82.7 | 72.6 / 67.1 | Both have omissions on hard layouts; PDF Craft is steadier overall |
| Structure & Navigation | 20% | 74.7 / 72.2 | 49.7 / 49.5 | 23–25 point lead: chapter TOC, heading hierarchy, and footnote links |
| Formulas & Tables | 15% | 71.1 / 71.1 | 26.7 / 26.7 | 44.4 point lead (identical across both reviewers): HTML tables & MathML vs. flattened text and broken math |
| Layout & Readability | 10% | 84.4 / 81.7 | 72.2 / 65.6 | Convertio often slices header bars as images, breaks lines into paragraphs, or turns plates into garbled tables |
| File Validity | 5% | 100.0 / 100.0 | 100.0 / 100.0 | Both produce valid, openable EPUB containers |
2. Per-Book Quality Comparison
| Book | Category | Pages | PDF Craft (Gemini / Deepseek) | Convertio (Gemini / Deepseek) | Practical Reading Differences |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Border Town | Literature | 187 | 67.6 / 74.7 | 46.5 / 54.1 | Convertio outputs only 2 TOC items, tags a library barcode as the sole <h1>, and turns a boat photo into a garbled table—though it read the place name "碧溪岨" right 14/20 times vs. PDF Craft's 0/23 |
| Alice Coloring Book | Literature | 20 | 94.9 / 95.7 | 74.1 / 74.9 | PDF Craft keeps text and all 10 images intact; Convertio frequently misreads italics (I→1, size→site/sire) and drops the color cover |
| Psychoanalytic Technique, Ch. 1 | Humanities | 24 | 88.0 / 87.6 | 65.3 / 59.4 | PDF Craft builds 21 working two-way footnote pairs; Convertio scrambles foreign citations, omits all footnote links, and inserts 10 sliced header bars as inline images |
| Baopuzi (Vol. 1) | Humanities | 10 | 61.6 / 60.6 | 58.0 / 52.5 | Both struggle on vertical classical Chinese with zero footnote links; Convertio lacks a TOC and creates garbled lines from wavy underlines, while PDF Craft misorders and drops commentary entries |
| Calculus Made Easy | STEM | 278 | 77.8 / 80.5 | 61.5 / 57.5 | PDF Craft keeps equations in MathML (though plain-text fallback collapses); Convertio uses no MathML, breaking inline and display equations into scattered fragments |
| MapVision (CVPR paper) | STEM | 5 | 74.5 / 71.2 | 65.2 / 64.5 | Convertio avoids PDF Craft's 3-sentence cross-column drop in section 2.6, but has no chapter TOC, shatters Figure 1 into 6 tiny fragments plus a fake table, and corrupts formula subscripts |
| HP Paper Trays Manual | Manual | 16 | 92.5 / 96.3 | 63.7 / 61.7 | Largest gap: PDF Craft retains all 4 <table> orientation charts and full TOC; Convertio flattens all 4 tables into spaced paragraphs and drops two major section headings and steps |
| Roman Mosaics (scanned) | Art Catalog | 12 | 67.0 / 67.6 | 71.8 / 63.5 | Only book where reviewers crossed: PDF Craft keeps plates but misplaces them across sections; Convertio drops a full-page plate and the map, turning the map into 20+ garbled blocks and tagging fl as <h1> |
| Roman Mosaics (native control) | Art Catalog | 88 | 68.8 / 69.4 | 68.8 / 64.1 | Excluded from main score: PDF Craft drops a paragraph and 15 endnotes; Convertio keeps body and endnote text without links, but drops cover/title plates and emits garbled tables |
Overall, Convertio's weakness is structural reconstruction: it outputs lightweight EPUB 2.0 files with missing or broken chapter TOCs on Border Town, Baopuzi, and MapVision, zero two-way footnote links across all books, and flattened tables or broken math. To be fair, Convertio was not behind on every single text detail—it handled a recurring place name better in Border Town, avoided the cross-column drop in MapVision, and retained full endnote text on the native art catalog.
Visual Output Comparisons
Each comparison image below shows three columns side by side: left = source PDF page, middle (Output A) = PDF Craft, right (Output B) = Convertio.
1. HP Manual (Three-Column Orientation Table)

PDF Craft preserves the real three-column table, headers, and cell borders. Convertio flattens the table into unbordered text lines and misreads the heading as Trayl.
2. Calculus Made Easy (Fractions and Math)

In a reader without MathML rendering, PDF Craft's plain-text fallback collapses fractions to (1 + 120)20 = 2.653 and ℒ100. Convertio misreads both the formula and numeric result ((1 + i)20 = 2.053), while slicing another fraction into a partial image.
3. Fundamentals of Psychoanalytic Technique (Prose and Footnotes)

PDF Craft keeps body paragraphs and end-of-section footnotes cleanly separated. Convertio merges footnote explanations into the main flow, introduces garbled characters, and splits words across inline numbers.
4. Border Town (Copyright and CIP Page)

PDF Craft preserves the CIP metadata with only one classification typo (IV.I246.5 → IV.1246.5). Convertio garbles the ISBN, Roman numerals, and barcode area.
5. Alice Coloring Book (English Prose)

On the same English page, PDF Craft is word-for-word accurate, whereas Convertio produces errors such as so retry remarkable, so ten much out of the way, and (tut of its uaistcoat-pocket.
6. Baopuzi (Vertical Classical Chinese and Commentary)

PDF Craft preserves the bracketed commentary numbers, while Convertio collapses note numbers directly into the surrounding prose.
7. MapVision (Two-Column Paper Continuation)

This is a clear case where Convertio did better: PDF Craft cuts off section 2.6 at ...passing them through the encoder in and jumps straight to section 2.7, whereas Convertio retains the continuation sentence from the right column.
8. Roman Mosaics (Scanned Art Catalog)

PDF Craft restores Figure 1 and its caption, while Convertio leaves only endnote text at that position with misspelled scholar names (Oziidogru / Dokii) and merged entries.
9. Roman Mosaics (Native Full-Page Plate Control)

On a full-page artwork plate, PDF Craft preserves the original image intact, whereas Convertio tries to OCR the mosaic into a page of garbled symbols.
3. Speed and Pricing Comparison
Per-Book Conversion Time
Timing scopes differ slightly (both exclude upload and download):
- PDF Craft: From API job acceptance to completion, including queueing, OCR, footnote refinement, and EPUB packaging.
- Convertio: From clicking convert to the first poll observing completion (about 13-second polling intervals), making Convertio's numbers upper bounds.
| Book | Pages | PDF Craft | Convertio | Speed Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Border Town | 187 | 31.0 min | ≤ 2.29 min | 13.5× |
| Alice Coloring Book | 20 | 3.1 min | ≤ 0.45 min | 6.9× |
| Psychoanalytic Technique, Ch. 1 | 24 | 6.0 min | ≤ 1.08 min | 5.6× |
| Baopuzi (Vol. 1) | 10 | 2.4 min | ≤ 0.44 min | 5.4× |
| Calculus Made Easy | 278 | 77.2 min | ≤ 3.21 min | 24.1× |
| MapVision (CVPR paper) | 5 | 2.4 min | ≤ 0.44 min | 5.4× |
| HP Paper Trays Manual | 16 | 5.0 min | ≤ 0.44 min | 11.3× |
| Roman Mosaics (scanned) | 12 | 5.0 min | ≤ 0.44 min | 11.3× |
| Roman Mosaics (native control) | 88 | 31.0 min | ≤ 1.73 min | 17.9× |
| Total | 640 | 163.1 min | ≤ 10.5 min | 15.5× |
Notes on timing:
- Average throughput was 25.5 minutes per 100 pages for PDF Craft vs. ≤ 1.64 minutes per 100 pages for Convertio.
- Long books show the widest gap (24.1× on Calculus Made Easy, 17.9× on the 88-page catalog) because PDF Craft performs full-book reflow and footnote refinement while Convertio emits lightweight EPUBs.
- MapVision was the first job in the batch and included cold-start overhead; use the total row for representative throughput. Convertio's 0.44-minute readings (about 26.6 seconds) sit near the polling floor, so actual times may be even shorter.
Speed and Pricing Overview
| Item | PDF Craft | Convertio (OCR Pack) | Comparison |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total time (640 pages) | 163.1 min | ≤ 10.5 min | Convertio is about 15.5× faster |
| Average speed | 25.5 min / 100 pages | ≤ 1.64 min / 100 pages | Widest gap on long books (up to 24×) |
| Billing model | Pay-as-you-go per page, no subscription (see Recharge) | Package / subscription (tested on the 1,000-page OCR pack) | PDF Craft is more flexible for occasional books |
| Price per 100 pages | Standard: $0.30 / 100 pages<br>Refined: $1.10 / 100 pages | $4.00 / 100 pages<br>($39.99 / 1,000 pages; 640 pages consumed) | Convertio costs 13× more than standard<br>3.6× more than refined |
| Effective cost (640 pages) | ~$1.92 standard / ~$7.04 refined | ~$25.60 effective usage | Minimum upfront OCR pack purchase is $39.99 |
Note: PDF Craft rates reflect current pricing on the Recharge page; Convertio pricing is calculated from the 1,000-page OCR pack used in this test.
4. Bottom Line
- Choose PDF Craft if you want a scanned book rebuilt into a real reading EPUB—especially with chapter navigation, HTML tables, MathML formulas, modern footnotes, or technical manuals—and you can wait roughly 25 minutes per 100 pages in the background. You get 20–45 points better structural fidelity at a fraction of the per-page cost.
- Choose Convertio if speed is your top priority (getting a lightweight, searchable EPUB in a couple of minutes), your PDFs are simple horizontal text without tables, math, or footnote links, and higher per-page OCR pricing is not a concern.
- Where neither tool is hands-free yet: vertical classical Chinese texts and endnote-heavy, multi-column art catalogs currently sit in the 60–70 range for both tools and still require manual proofreading and cleanup.
