# PDF Craft vs Convertio: Scanned PDF to EPUB Quality, Speed, and Pricing

Side-by-side blind benchmark of PDF Craft and Convertio across 9 books (121 sampled pages), comparing EPUB structure, tables, math, conversion speed, and per-page pricing.

Across the same 9 test books (121 sampled pages) in an anonymized blind test, **PDF Craft scored 78.6–80.0 while Convertio scored 61.0–63.1—a 15.5 to 19.0 point lead for PDF Craft**. At the same time, **Convertio ran about 15× faster**, while **Convertio's OCR page pack cost 3.6× to 13× more per 100 pages**. The real divide is not occasional OCR typos; it is whether the converter can reassemble recognized text back into a properly structured book.

The full 6-dimension rubric, book list, four-tier scoring scale, and scope limitations are documented in [Scanned PDF to EPUB Benchmark: Methodology and PDF Craft Test Results](https://pdfcraft.ai/blog/pdf-to-epub-benchmark-and-self-test/). Below are the head-to-head results from independent blind reviews by Gemini and Deepseek on the same anonymized package.

## 1. Overall and Dimension Scores

### Weighted Overall Score (Original-Language Scanned PDF to EPUB)

| Converter                              | Gemini Blind Review | Deepseek Blind Review | Summary                                                   |
| -------------------------------------- | ------------------: | --------------------: | --------------------------------------------------------- |
| **PDF Craft**                          |            **78.6** |              **80.0** | Both blind reviews agree, ahead by 15.5–19.0 points       |
| **Convertio**                          |            **63.1** |              **61.0** | Very fast, but loses heavily on TOC, tables, and formulas |
| **Difference (PDF Craft − Convertio)** |           **+15.5** |             **+19.0** | —                                                         |

### Average Scores Across All Six Dimensions

| Dimension                  | Weight | PDF Craft (Gemini / Deepseek) | Convertio (Gemini / Deepseek) | Key Takeaway                                                                                                    |
| -------------------------- | -----: | :---------------------------: | :---------------------------: | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Text Accuracy              |    30% |          72.3 / 76.3          |          64.5 / 63.3          | Only an 8–13 point gap; raw text is not the main divide                                                         |
| Completeness               |    20% |          79.3 / 82.7          |          72.6 / 67.1          | Both have omissions on hard layouts; PDF Craft is steadier overall                                              |
| **Structure & Navigation** |    20% |        **74.7 / 72.2**        |        **49.7 / 49.5**        | **23–25 point lead**: chapter TOC, heading hierarchy, and footnote links                                        |
| **Formulas & Tables**      |    15% |        **71.1 / 71.1**        |        **26.7 / 26.7**        | **44.4 point lead** (identical across both reviewers): HTML tables & MathML vs. flattened text and broken math  |
| Layout & Readability       |    10% |          84.4 / 81.7          |          72.2 / 65.6          | Convertio often slices header bars as images, breaks lines into paragraphs, or turns plates into garbled tables |
| File Validity              |     5% |         100.0 / 100.0         |         100.0 / 100.0         | Both produce valid, openable EPUB containers                                                                    |

## 2. Per-Book Quality Comparison

| Book                              | Category    | Pages | PDF Craft (Gemini / Deepseek) | Convertio (Gemini / Deepseek) | Practical Reading Differences                                                                                                                                                                                   |
| --------------------------------- | ----------- | ----: | :---------------------------: | :---------------------------: | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| *Border Town*                     | Literature  |   187 |        **67.6 / 74.7**        |          46.5 / 54.1          | Convertio outputs only 2 TOC items, tags a library barcode as the sole `<h1>`, and turns a boat photo into a garbled table—though it read the place name "碧溪岨" right 14/20 times vs. PDF Craft's 0/23           |
| *Alice* Coloring Book             | Literature  |    20 |        **94.9 / 95.7**        |          74.1 / 74.9          | PDF Craft keeps text and all 10 images intact; Convertio frequently misreads italics (`I`→`1`, `size`→`site`/`sire`) and drops the color cover                                                                  |
| *Psychoanalytic Technique*, Ch. 1 | Humanities  |    24 |        **88.0 / 87.6**        |          65.3 / 59.4          | PDF Craft builds 21 working two-way footnote pairs; Convertio scrambles foreign citations, omits all footnote links, and inserts 10 sliced header bars as inline images                                         |
| *Baopuzi* (Vol. 1)                | Humanities  |    10 |        **61.6 / 60.6**        |          58.0 / 52.5          | Both struggle on vertical classical Chinese with zero footnote links; Convertio lacks a TOC and creates garbled lines from wavy underlines, while PDF Craft misorders and drops commentary entries              |
| *Calculus Made Easy*              | STEM        |   278 |        **77.8 / 80.5**        |          61.5 / 57.5          | PDF Craft keeps equations in MathML (though plain-text fallback collapses); Convertio uses no MathML, breaking inline and display equations into scattered fragments                                            |
| *MapVision* (CVPR paper)          | STEM        |     5 |        **74.5 / 71.2**        |          65.2 / 64.5          | Convertio avoids PDF Craft's 3-sentence cross-column drop in section 2.6, but has no chapter TOC, shatters Figure 1 into 6 tiny fragments plus a fake table, and corrupts formula subscripts                    |
| *HP Paper Trays* Manual           | Manual      |    16 |        **92.5 / 96.3**        |          63.7 / 61.7          | Largest gap: PDF Craft retains all 4 `<table>` orientation charts and full TOC; Convertio flattens all 4 tables into spaced paragraphs and drops two major section headings and steps                           |
| *Roman Mosaics* (scanned)         | Art Catalog |    12 |        67.0 / **67.6**        |        **71.8** / 63.5        | Only book where reviewers crossed: PDF Craft keeps plates but misplaces them across sections; Convertio drops a full-page plate and the map, turning the map into 20+ garbled blocks and tagging `fl` as `<h1>` |
| *Roman Mosaics* (native control)  | Art Catalog |    88 |        **68.8 / 69.4**        |          68.8 / 64.1          | Excluded from main score: PDF Craft drops a paragraph and 15 endnotes; Convertio keeps body and endnote text without links, but drops cover/title plates and emits garbled tables                               |

Overall, **Convertio's weakness is structural reconstruction**: it outputs lightweight EPUB 2.0 files with missing or broken chapter TOCs on *Border Town*, *Baopuzi*, and *MapVision*, zero two-way footnote links across all books, and flattened tables or broken math. To be fair, Convertio was not behind on every single text detail—it handled a recurring place name better in *Border Town*, avoided the cross-column drop in *MapVision*, and retained full endnote text on the native art catalog.

### Visual Output Comparisons

Each comparison image below shows three columns side by side: **left = source PDF page, middle (Output A) = PDF Craft, right (Output B) = Convertio**.

#### 1. HP Manual (Three-Column Orientation Table)

![HP manual table comparison: source page, PDF Craft, and Convertio](https://pdfcraft.ai/blog-assets/pdf-craft-vs-convertio-pdf-to-epub/hp-manual-table.webp "Left: source page; middle: PDF Craft preserves the bordered 3-column HTML table; right: Convertio flattens it to plain text lines and misreads Tray 1 as Trayl")

PDF Craft preserves the real three-column table, headers, and cell borders. Convertio flattens the table into unbordered text lines and misreads the heading as `Trayl`.

#### 2. Calculus Made Easy (Fractions and Math)

![Calculus Made Easy formula comparison: source page, PDF Craft, and Convertio](https://pdfcraft.ai/blog-assets/pdf-craft-vs-convertio-pdf-to-epub/calculus-formulas.webp "Left: source page; middle: PDF Craft plain-text math fallback collapses without MathML rendering; right: Convertio corrupts both fractions and digits")

In a reader without MathML rendering, PDF Craft's plain-text fallback collapses fractions to `(1 + 120)20 = 2.653` and `ℒ100`. Convertio misreads both the formula and numeric result (`(1 + i)20 = 2.053`), while slicing another fraction into a partial image.

#### 3. Fundamentals of Psychoanalytic Technique (Prose and Footnotes)

![Psychoanalytic Technique footnote comparison: source page, PDF Craft, and Convertio](https://pdfcraft.ai/blog-assets/pdf-craft-vs-convertio-pdf-to-epub/psychoanalysis-footnotes.webp "Left: source page; middle: PDF Craft separates body prose and footnotes cleanly; right: Convertio merges notes into body text with garbled symbols")

PDF Craft keeps body paragraphs and end-of-section footnotes cleanly separated. Convertio merges footnote explanations into the main flow, introduces garbled characters, and splits words across inline numbers.

#### 4. Border Town (Copyright and CIP Page)

![Border Town copyright page comparison: source page, PDF Craft, and Convertio](https://pdfcraft.ai/blog-assets/pdf-craft-vs-convertio-pdf-to-epub/border-town-cip.webp "Left: source page; middle: PDF Craft keeps CIP fields largely intact; right: Convertio garbles the ISBN and barcode block")

PDF Craft preserves the CIP metadata with only one classification typo (`IV.I246.5` → `IV.1246.5`). Convertio garbles the ISBN, Roman numerals, and barcode area.

#### 5. Alice Coloring Book (English Prose)

![Alice Coloring Book text comparison: source page, PDF Craft, and Convertio](https://pdfcraft.ai/blog-assets/pdf-craft-vs-convertio-pdf-to-epub/alice-body.webp "Left: source page; middle: PDF Craft matches the page word for word; right: Convertio misreads italics and common words")

On the same English page, PDF Craft is word-for-word accurate, whereas Convertio produces errors such as `so retry remarkable`, `so ten much out of the way`, and `(tut of its uaistcoat-pocket`.

#### 6. Baopuzi (Vertical Classical Chinese and Commentary)

![Baopuzi classical Chinese comparison: source page, PDF Craft, and Convertio](https://pdfcraft.ai/blog-assets/pdf-craft-vs-convertio-pdf-to-epub/baopuzi-classical.webp "Left: source page; middle: PDF Craft retains commentary numbering; right: Convertio collapses note numbers into body text")

PDF Craft preserves the bracketed commentary numbers, while Convertio collapses note numbers directly into the surrounding prose.

#### 7. MapVision (Two-Column Paper Continuation)

![MapVision two-column paper comparison: source page, PDF Craft, and Convertio](https://pdfcraft.ai/blog-assets/pdf-craft-vs-convertio-pdf-to-epub/mapvision-columns.webp "Left: source page; middle: PDF Craft truncates section 2.6 across columns; right: Convertio keeps the continuation intact")

This is a clear case where Convertio did better: PDF Craft cuts off section 2.6 at `...passing them through the encoder in` and jumps straight to section 2.7, whereas Convertio retains the continuation sentence from the right column.

#### 8. Roman Mosaics (Scanned Art Catalog)

![Scanned Roman Mosaics comparison: source page, PDF Craft, and Convertio](https://pdfcraft.ai/blog-assets/pdf-craft-vs-convertio-pdf-to-epub/mosaics-scan-plate.webp "Left: source page; middle: PDF Craft restores Figure 1 and its caption; right: Convertio leaves only endnotes with misspelled names")

PDF Craft restores Figure 1 and its caption, while Convertio leaves only endnote text at that position with misspelled scholar names (`Oziidogru` / `Dokii`) and merged entries.

#### 9. Roman Mosaics (Native Full-Page Plate Control)

![Native Roman Mosaics full-page plate comparison: source page, PDF Craft, and Convertio](https://pdfcraft.ai/blog-assets/pdf-craft-vs-convertio-pdf-to-epub/mosaics-native-plate.webp "Left: source page; middle: PDF Craft preserves the full-page plate; right: Convertio turns the full-page artwork into garbled symbols")

On a full-page artwork plate, PDF Craft preserves the original image intact, whereas Convertio tries to OCR the mosaic into a page of garbled symbols.

## 3. Speed and Pricing Comparison

### Per-Book Conversion Time

Timing scopes differ slightly (both exclude upload and download):

* **PDF Craft**: From API job acceptance to completion, including queueing, OCR, footnote refinement, and EPUB packaging.
* **Convertio**: From clicking convert to the first poll observing completion (about 13-second polling intervals), making Convertio's numbers **upper bounds**.

| Book                              |   Pages |     PDF Craft |      Convertio | Speed Ratio |
| --------------------------------- | ------: | ------------: | -------------: | ----------: |
| *Border Town*                     |     187 |      31.0 min |     ≤ 2.29 min |       13.5× |
| *Alice* Coloring Book             |      20 |       3.1 min |     ≤ 0.45 min |        6.9× |
| *Psychoanalytic Technique*, Ch. 1 |      24 |       6.0 min |     ≤ 1.08 min |        5.6× |
| *Baopuzi* (Vol. 1)                |      10 |       2.4 min |     ≤ 0.44 min |        5.4× |
| *Calculus Made Easy*              |     278 |      77.2 min |     ≤ 3.21 min |       24.1× |
| *MapVision* (CVPR paper)          |       5 |       2.4 min |     ≤ 0.44 min |        5.4× |
| *HP Paper Trays* Manual           |      16 |       5.0 min |     ≤ 0.44 min |       11.3× |
| *Roman Mosaics* (scanned)         |      12 |       5.0 min |     ≤ 0.44 min |       11.3× |
| *Roman Mosaics* (native control)  |      88 |      31.0 min |     ≤ 1.73 min |       17.9× |
| **Total**                         | **640** | **163.1 min** | **≤ 10.5 min** |   **15.5×** |

Notes on timing:

* Average throughput was **25.5 minutes per 100 pages** for PDF Craft vs. **≤ 1.64 minutes per 100 pages** for Convertio.
* Long books show the widest gap (24.1× on *Calculus Made Easy*, 17.9× on the 88-page catalog) because PDF Craft performs full-book reflow and footnote refinement while Convertio emits lightweight EPUBs.
* *MapVision* was the first job in the batch and included cold-start overhead; use the total row for representative throughput. Convertio's 0.44-minute readings (about 26.6 seconds) sit near the polling floor, so actual times may be even shorter.

### Speed and Pricing Overview

| Item                           | PDF Craft                                                                               | Convertio (OCR Pack)                                                | Comparison                                                               |
| ------------------------------ | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------ |
| **Total time (640 pages)**     | 163.1 min                                                                               | ≤ 10.5 min                                                          | Convertio is about **15.5× faster**                                      |
| **Average speed**              | 25.5 min / 100 pages                                                                    | ≤ 1.64 min / 100 pages                                              | Widest gap on long books (up to 24×)                                     |
| **Billing model**              | Pay-as-you-go per page, no subscription (see [Recharge](https://pdfcraft.ai/recharge/)) | Package / subscription (tested on the 1,000-page OCR pack)          | PDF Craft is more flexible for occasional books                          |
| **Price per 100 pages**        | Standard: **$0.30 / 100 pages**<br>Refined: **$1.10 / 100 pages**                       | **$4.00 / 100 pages**<br>($39.99 / 1,000 pages; 640 pages consumed) | Convertio costs **13× more** than standard<br>**3.6× more** than refined |
| **Effective cost (640 pages)** | \~$1.92 standard / \~$7.04 refined                                                      | \~$25.60 effective usage                                            | Minimum upfront OCR pack purchase is $39.99                              |

> Note: PDF Craft rates reflect current pricing on the [Recharge page](https://pdfcraft.ai/recharge/); Convertio pricing is calculated from the 1,000-page OCR pack used in this test.

## 4. Bottom Line

* **Choose PDF Craft** if you want a scanned book rebuilt into a real reading EPUB—especially with **chapter navigation, HTML tables, MathML formulas, modern footnotes, or technical manuals**—and you can wait roughly 25 minutes per 100 pages in the background. You get 20–45 points better structural fidelity at a fraction of the per-page cost.
* **Choose Convertio** if **speed** is your top priority (getting a lightweight, searchable EPUB in a couple of minutes), your PDFs are simple horizontal text without tables, math, or footnote links, and higher per-page OCR pricing is not a concern.
* **Where neither tool is hands-free yet**: **vertical classical Chinese texts** and **endnote-heavy, multi-column art catalogs** currently sit in the 60–70 range for both tools and still require manual proofreading and cleanup.

